The Wall Street Journal: The Jobs Picture Still Looks Bleak
Many outsourced jobs will never return, and median income will likely continue to fall just like it did during the last so-called recovery. |
|
APRIL 12, 2010
THE WALL STREET JOURNAL By ROBERT REICH
The U.S. economy added 162,000 jobs in March. That sounds impressive until you look more closely. At least a third of them were temporary government hires to take the census—better than no job but hardly worth writing home about. The 112,000 real new jobs were fewer than the 150,000 needed to keep up with the growth of the U.S. population. It's far better than it was—we're not hemorrhaging jobs as we did in 2008 and 2009—but the bleeding hasn't stopped.
Since the start of the Great Recession in December 2007, the economy has shed 8.4 million jobs and failed to create another 2.7 million required by an ever-larger pool of potential workers. That leaves us more than 11 million jobs behind. (The number is worse if you include everyone working part-time who'd rather it be full-time, those working full-time at fewer hours, and people who are overqualified for the jobs they're in.) This means even if we enjoy a vigorous recovery that produces, say, 300,000 net new jobs a month, we could be looking at five to eight years before catching up to where we were before the recession began.
Given how many Americans are unemployed or underemployed, it's hard to see where we get sufficient demand to support a vigorous recovery. Outlays from the federal stimulus have already passed their peak, and the Federal Reserve won't keep interest rates near zero for very long. Although consumers are beginning to come out of their holes, it will be many years before they can return to their pre-recession levels of spending. Most households rely on two wage earners, of whom at least one is now likely to be unemployed, underemployed or in danger of losing a job. And even households whose incomes have returned are likely to be residing in houses whose values haven't—which means they can't turn their homes into cash machines as they did before the recession.
While consumers have been shedding their debts like mad—often simply by defaulting on loans—their remaining burdens are still heavy. At the end of last year, debt averaged $43,874 per American, or about 122% of annual disposable income. Most analysts believe a sustainable debt load is around 100% of disposable income, assuming a normal level of employment and normal access to credit—neither of which we are likely to have for some time.
Some economic cheerleaders say rising stock prices are making consumers feel wealthier and therefore readier to spend. But most Americans' biggest asset is their homes. The "wealth effect" is felt mainly by the richest 10%, whose net worth is largely stocks and bonds. The top 10% accounted for about half of total national income in 2007. But they were only about 40% of total spending. A vigorous jobs recovery can't be based on 40% of what was spent before the economy collapsed.
What's likely to slow the jobs recovery most, however, is the indubitable reality that many of the jobs that have been lost will never return.
The Great Recession has accelerated a structural shift in the economy that had been slowly building for years. Companies have used the downturn to aggressively trim payrolls, making cuts they've been reluctant to make before. Outsourcing abroad has increased dramatically. Companies have discovered that new software and computer technologies have made many workers in Asia and Latin America almost as productive as Americans, and that the Internet allows far more work to be efficiently moved to another country without loss of control.
Companies have also cut costs by substituting more computerized equipment for labor. They've made greater use of numerically controlled machine tools, robotics and a wide range of office software.
These cost-cutting moves have allowed many companies to show profits notwithstanding relatively poor sales. Alcoa, for example, had $1.5 billion in cash at the end of last year, double what it had on hand at the end of 2008. It managed this largely by cutting 28,000 jobs, 32% of its work force. But for workers, there's no return. Those who have lost their jobs to foreign outsourcing or labor-replacing technologies are unlikely ever to get them back. And they have little hope of finding new jobs that pay as well. More than 40% of today's unemployed have been without work for over six months, a higher proportion than at any time in 60 years.
The only way many of today's jobless are likely to retain their jobs or get new ones is by settling for much lower wages and benefits. The official unemployment numbers hide the extent to which American workers are already on this downward path. But if you look at income data you'll see the drop.
Among those with jobs, more and more have accepted lower pay and benefits as a condition for keeping them. Or they have lost higher-paying jobs and are now in new ones that pay less. Or new hires are paid far lower wages than the old. (In January, Ford Motor Co. announced that it would add 1,200 jobs at its Chicago assembly plant but didn't trumpet that the new workers will be paid half of what current workers were paid when they began.) Or they have become consultants or temporary workers whose pay is unsteady and benefits nonexistent.
This shift also helps explain why the unemployment rate for Americans with college degrees is now only 5%, while it is 10.5% for those with only a high-school degree, and 15.6% for Americans with less than a high-school diploma. The jobs of well-educated Americans, although hardly immune to foreign outsourcing and technological displacement, have been less vulnerable to these trends than the jobs of Americans with fewer years of education.
The likelihood, therefore, is that as the economy struggles to recover and today's jobless begin to find work, the median wage will continue to fall—as it did between 2001 and 2007, during the last so-called recovery.
More Americans will be working, but for pay they consider inadequate. The approaching recovery will be tepid because so many people will lack the money needed to buy all the goods and services the economy can produce.
Americans will once again be employed, but they will also be back on the downward escalator of declining pay they rode before the Great Recession.
Mr. Reich, professor of public policy at the University of California at Berkeley and former secretary of labor under President Clinton, is author of the forthcoming "Aftershock: The Next Economy and America's Future" (Alfred A. Knopf).
Note: To view this article, click here.
Related Documents
October 14, 2010
“It's not about tactics or about positioning or messaging. What the president seems to continue to miss is it’s...
October 08, 2010
“I’m also a mother. I’m a wife. I’m an American veteran, and I’m one of your middle-class Americans. And,...
September 24, 2010
“It’s about jobs. In its life, [the healthcare bill] will create 4 million jobs—400,000 jobs almost immediately.” –Speaker Nancy...
September 09, 2010
Washington, DC - U.S. Congressman Mike Pence, Chairman of the House Republican Conference, discussed the President’s speech on more...
September 08, 2010
Tax Increases on Small Businesses Claim: President Obama: “We are ready, this week, to give tax cuts to every...
July 15, 2010
Washington, DC - U.S. Congressman Mike Pence, Chairman of the House Republican Conference delivered the following remarks on...
July 15, 2010
House Republican Conference Chairman Mike Pence appeared on Fox News today, discussing the White House claim of job saving...
July 06, 2010
Rep. Aaron Schock (IL) wasn't happy to find out how much federal money was being spent on stimulus signs...
July 01, 2010
President Obama attempts to convince struggling families that the ‘stimulus’ worked: “So part of the challenge in delivering this message...
May 28, 2010
U.S. Congressman Mike Pence, Chairman of the House Republican Conference, delivered the following remarks on the House floor today:...
May 10, 2010
Latest Near $1 Trillion Bailout of Euro Comes on the Heels of Bailout for Greece Washington, D.C. -- U.S....
May 07, 2010
"Greece is going to default despite all the talk, despite the liquidity package. Martin Feldstein, Harvard...
April 22, 2010
“The American people want Congress to change the way we spend the people’s money.” Washington, DC - U.S. Congressman...
April 21, 2010
Republican Leadership Press Conference April 21, 2010 Participants: - Republican Leader John Boehner (R-OH) - Republican Whip Eric Cantor...
March 18, 2010
At today's White House Press Briefing, Press Secretary Robert Gibbs implied that American taxpayers might see more "savings" in...
January 27, 2010
Republican Leadership Press Conference January 27, 2010 Participants: - Republican Leader John Boehner (R-OH) - Republican Whip Eric...
January 27, 2010
Washington, DC - U.S. Congressman Mike Pence, Chairman of the House Republican Conference, delivered the following remarks today on...
January 27, 2010
Washington, DC - U.S. Congressman Mike Pence, Chairman of the House Republican Conference, delivered the following remarks today on...
January 13, 2010
Republican Leadership Press Conference January 13, 2010 Participants: - Republican Whip Eric Cantor (R-VA) - Conference Chair Mike...
January 08, 2010
Today, President Obama said that his stimulus bill was "a major force in breaking the trajectory of this recession...
December 16, 2009
Washington, DC - U.S. Congressman Mike Pence, Chairman of the House Republican Conference, delivered the following remarks today on...
December 16, 2009
Republican Leadership Press Conference December 16, 2009 Participants: - Republican Leader John Boehner (R-OH) - Republican Whip Eric Cantor...
December 08, 2009
Republican Leadership Press Conference December 8, 2009 Participants: - Republican Leader John Boehner (R-OH) - Republican Whip Eric...
December 08, 2009
Washington, DC - U.S. Congressman Mike Pence, Chairman of the House Republican Conference, delivered the following remarks today on...
December 02, 2009
Republican Leadership Press Conference December 2, 2009 Participants: - Republican Leader John Boehner (R-OH) - Republican Whip Eric...
December 01, 2009
Since passage of the Democrats' trillion dollar "stimulus," more than 2.8 million jobs have been lost and unemployment stands at...
November 06, 2009
House Republican Conference Chairman Mike Pence has a lot to say about the unemployment numbers released this morning: The...
October 14, 2009
Washington, DC - U.S. Congressman Mike Pence, Chairman of the House Republican Conference, delivered the following remarks today on the floor of...
August 03, 2009
Congressman Mike Pence: “The focus right now for the American people is on the role...
July 22, 2009
To view this clip, click here. Transcript below: [Clip of Hoyer on the House floor] ...
July 22, 2009
President's Economic Fiction White House Chief of Staff, Rahm Emanuel: "Rahm Emanuel, the White House chief of staff,...
July 21, 2009
Washington, DC - U.S. Congressman Mike Pence, Chairman of the House Republican Conference, made the following statement on the...
July 17, 2009
"Now most of the money that we're investing as part of this plan will get out the door immediately...
July 17, 2009
Washington, DC - The House Republican Conference unveiled the following video today on MSNBC's Morning Joe. As reports continue...
July 13, 2009
What the economy "is going through is a very necessary and healthy adjustment as [Americans] go back to living within...
July 09, 2009
Washington, DC - The House Republican Conference unveiled the following hard-hitting jobs video on Hannity last night. In the...
July 09, 2009
"The American people are starting to get wise to the Democrat plan here. They understand the Democrat agenda is...
June 09, 2009
Washington, DC - U.S. Congressman Mike Pence, Chairman of the House Republican Conference, made the following statement on the...
June 02, 2009
The latest from Conference Call: In an attempt to justify Democrats’ massive $1 trillion “stimulus,” the Administration “plays...
June 01, 2009
"In these last few months, the American Recovery and Reinvestment Act has saved or created nearly 150,000 jobs."...
May 13, 2009
By Carol D. Leonnig Tuesday, May 12, 2009 5:58 PM The Federal Aviation Administration, after reviewing concerns about...
May 12, 2009
Budget Shortfalls Prompt Mass Layoffs By Alec MacGillis Washington Post Staff Writer Tuesday, May 12, 2009 Eleven weeks...
May 11, 2009
Only thing sorrier than President's ‘cuts' is reaction on Capitol Hill By: Keith Simmons When...
May 11, 2009
Counties suffering the most from job losses stand to receive the least help from President Barack Obama's plan...
May 11, 2009
President Obama's chief economics forecaster said on Sunday that the country was not likely to see positive employment growth...
May 11, 2009
"The AP findings suggest the White House raised expectations too high for the transportation spending, said a spokesman for...
May 11, 2009
When it comes to federal spending, there's a pattern emerging with President Obama, and it's not a...
May 11, 2009
President Obama's chief economics forecaster said on Sunday that the country was not likely to see positive...
April 23, 2009
by Rep. Erik Paulsen (MN) Yesterday, a report was issued by the special inspector overseeing the Troubled Asset Relief...
April 20, 2009
by Rep. Robert Aderholt (AL-04) Last week’s Tea Parties were a powerful message to Washington in protest to the...
April 20, 2009
House Leader John Boehner appeared yesterday on "This Week" with George Stephanopoulos, saying legislators should beware of "trillion dollar...
April 08, 2009
WASHINGTON - The federal government will soon send more than $300 million in stimulus funds to 61 housing agencies...
April 01, 2009
It was a special day for Republicans on Capitol Hill, as House and Senate leaders gathered for a...
March 26, 2009
House Republicans today released the "Republican Road to Recovery," an 18-page booklet specificying the steps they will take to...
March 25, 2009
House Leader John Boehner's office was quick to break down President Obama's address to the nation last night. After...
March 24, 2009
House Whip Eric Cantor's office has done a great job compiling facts for Republicans to lean on as America's...
March 23, 2009
House Republicans want you to know there is a better way and we've got an alternative plan that is...
March 23, 2009
Rep. Jeff Flake (AZ) gets a few words in at the American Spectator this morning, offering insight from the...
March 18, 2009
THAT WAS THEN: On February 12, President Obama visited employees at an Illinois Caterpillar plant and said, "when they...
March 05, 2009
President Obama said government-run health care was “extreme” and “wrong” but… Then-Candidate Obama said government- run health care was...
March 04, 2009
President Obama says he supports slashing earmarks and making all spending decisions open to the public… President Obama Pledges...
March 03, 2009
President Obama promises that taxpayers making less than $250,000 would not have their taxes "increased a single dime." President Barack...
February 11, 2009
U.S. Congressman Mike Pence, Chairman of the House Republican Conference, made the following statement today in response to reports...
February 11, 2009
New York Post: CONGRESS $HOPPING CARTS
Access the original article here. By GEOFF EARLE Post Correspondent ELECTRIC...
|
|