VA Administrative Investigations:
Improvements Needed in Collecting and Sharing Information
GAO-12-483: Published: Apr 30, 2012. Publicly Released: May 30, 2012.
Additional Materials:
- Highlights Page:
- Full Report:
- Accessible Text:
Contact:
(202) 512-7114
draperd@gao.gov
Office of Public Affairs
(202) 512-4800
youngc1@gao.gov
What GAO Found
The Department of Veterans Affairs (VA) has departmentwide policy and procedures for convening and conducting administrative investigation boards (AIB). The departments procedures contain requirements for convening and conducting AIB investigations, but according to VA officials, they also provide the flexibility to tailor an investigation to effectively meet diverse informational needs. For example, the VA official convening an AIB investigation is required to select AIB members who are impartial and objective, but has flexibility to vary the number of members appointed to each AIB based on the matter being investigated. VA is currently updating its AIB policy and procedures, but officials said the department plans to maintain flexibility in its AIB process.
VA does not collect and analyze aggregate data on AIB investigations, including data on the number of AIB investigations conducted, the types of matters investigated, and whether the matters were substantiated, or on any systemic deficiencies identified by AIBs. Having aggregate data could provide VA with valuable information to systematically gauge the extent to which matters investigated by AIBs may be occurring throughout VAs Veterans Health Administration (VHA) and to take corrective action, if needed, to reduce the likelihood of future occurrences. Without such data, VA is unable to adequately assess the causes or factors that may contribute to deficiencies occurring within its medical centers and health care networks. Information on AIB investigations is maintained by different offices across VA. For example, each medical center or network maintains information on each AIB investigation that it conducts. In response to GAOs request for AIB data, VHA administered a web-based survey that collected data from all its medical centers and networks on AIB investigations they reported conducting during fiscal years 2009 through 2011. Survey data showed that medical centers and networks conducted more than 1,100 investigations during this time period, and the types of matters investigated included allegations of inappropriate employee behavior involving patients and other employees; individual employee wrongdoing, such as theft and fraud; and systemic deficiencies. VHA officials told us that although it administered the web-based survey, the department has no plans to collect and analyze aggregate data on AIB investigations conducted within VHA.
VA has used the results of AIB investigations to inform corrective actions, but does not share information about improvements made that could have broader applicability. Specifically, VA has used the results of AIB investigations to inform systemic changes at the medical centers and networks where AIB investigations have been conducted. For example, VA has developed new policies and procedures for improving patient and employee safety and developed new training programs to expand employees knowledge of VA policies and procedures. However, VA does not share information about these improvements that may have relevance for other areas within VHA. Such information could be used to improve not only the quality of patient care provided, but also the efficiency of VHAs overall operations. For example, one medical center included in GAOs review implemented a tracking system to ensure surgical instruments are delivered promptly to the operating room and a checklist to ensure the availability of needed equipment prior to starting surgery.
Why GAO Did This Study
VA may use an AIB to determine the facts surrounding alleged employee misconduct or potential systemic deficiencies related to VA policies or procedures. AIBs do not determine corrective actions, such as individual disciplinary actions or procedural changes, but AIB investigation results, including evidence, may be used to inform such actions, making it critical for AIBs to be convened and conducted appropriately.
You expressed interest in the number of AIB investigations and their results. In this report, GAO examines (1) the process VA uses to convene and conduct AIB investigations, (2) the extent to which VA collects data on AIB investigations, and (3) how VA has used the results of its AIB investigations. GAO focused on AIB investigations conducted within VHA; reviewed VA documents, including policies and procedures, and VHA data on AIBs conducted during fiscal years 2009 through 2011; and interviewed VA officials from headquarters and four medical centers. To ensure data reliability, GAO reviewed VHAs methods to collect AIB data.
What GAO Recommends
GAO recommends that VA establish processes to (1) collect and analyze aggregate data from AIB investigations conducted within VHA, and (2) share information about improvements that are implemented in response to the results of AIB investigations. VA concurred with these recommendations.
For more information, contact Debra A. Draper at (202) 512-7114 or draperd@gao.gov.
Recommendations for Executive Action
Status: Open
Comments: VA concurred with this recommendation and noted that it would explore any new processes for collecting and analyzing aggregate data from AIB investigations. In September 2015, VA reported that VHA had established a working group to review this recommendation and also had created a database to collect and analyze aggregate data from AIB investigations into senior executive service (SES) employees. Based on an informal survey of its working group as well as its analysis of AIB data for SES employees, VA stated that central office oversight of the AIB process is not needed and that several systems already in place capture data on system-wide risks (e.g., sexual assault reporting, Issue Briefs, and National Center for Patient Safety Patient Safety Information System Program). Ultimately, VA stated that it could not justify the resources needed to implement this recommendation.
Recommendation: To systematically gauge the extent to which deficiencies identified by individual AIBs may be occurring throughout VHA; and to maximize opportunities for sharing information across VHA to improve its overall operations, the Secretary of Veterans Affairs should direct the Under Secretary for Health to establish a process to collect and analyze aggregate data from AIB investigations, including the number of investigations conducted, the types of matters investigated, whether the matters were substantiated, and systemic deficiencies identified.
Agency Affected: Department of Veterans Affairs
Status: Open
Comments: VA concurred with this recommendation and noted that it would explore any new processes for collecting and analyzing aggregate data from AIB investigations. In September 2015, VA reported that it had established a working group to review this recommendation. In addition, VA also had created a database to collect and analyze aggregate data from AIB investigations into senior executive service (SES) employees to identify trends and address deficiencies. Based on an informal survey of its working group and its analysis of AIB data for SES employees, VA stated that VISNs currently provide adequate oversight of the AIB process and notify VA central office when appropriate and that a comprehensive review of its AIB data for SES employees identified no system-wide issues. Ultimately, VA stated that it could not justify the resources needed to implement this recommendation.
Recommendation: To systematically gauge the extent to which deficiencies identified by individual AIBs may be occurring throughout VHA; and to maximize opportunities for sharing information across VHA to improve its overall operations, the Secretary of Veterans Affairs should direct the Under Secretary for Health to establish a process for sharing information about systemic changes, including policies and procedures implemented in response to the results of AIB investigations, which may have broader applicability throughout VHA.
Agency Affected: Department of Veterans Affairs
Explore the full database of GAO's Open Recommendations »
Oct 27, 2016
-
VA Health Care:
Processes to Evaluate, Implement, and Monitor Organizational Structure Changes NeededGAO-16-803: Published: Sep 27, 2016. Publicly Released: Oct 27, 2016.
Sep 28, 2016
-
VA Real Property:
VA Should Better Justify Its Need to Lease Major Medical FacilitiesGAO-16-884T: Published: Sep 28, 2016. Publicly Released: Sep 28, 2016.
Sep 20, 2016
-
Veterans Affairs Contracting:
Improvements in Policies and Processes Could Yield Cost Savings and EfficiencyGAO-16-867T: Published: Sep 20, 2016. Publicly Released: Sep 20, 2016.
Sep 19, 2016
-
Veterans' Health Care:
Improved Oversight of Community Care Physicians' Credentials NeededGAO-16-795: Published: Sep 19, 2016. Publicly Released: Sep 19, 2016.
Sep 16, 2016
-
Veterans Affairs Contracting:
Improvements in Policies and Processes Could Yield Cost Savings and EfficiencyGAO-16-810: Published: Sep 16, 2016. Publicly Released: Sep 16, 2016.
Jul 29, 2016
-
Veterans Health Administration:
Personnel Data Show Losses Increased for Clinical Occupations from Fiscal Year 2011 through 2015, Driven by Voluntary Resignations and RetirementsGAO-16-666R: Published: Jul 29, 2016. Publicly Released: Jul 29, 2016.
Jul 28, 2016
-
VA Real Property:
Leasing Can Provide Flexibility to Meet Needs but VA Should Demonstrate the BenefitsGAO-16-619: Published: Jun 28, 2016. Publicly Released: Jul 28, 2016.
Jun 27, 2016
-
Veterans Crisis Line:
Additional Testing, Monitoring, and Information Needed to Ensure Better Quality ServiceGAO-16-373: Published: May 26, 2016. Publicly Released: Jun 27, 2016.
Jun 6, 2016
-
VA Health Care:
Improvements Needed for Management and Oversight of Sole- Source Affiliate Contract DevelopmentGAO-16-426: Published: May 6, 2016. Publicly Released: Jun 6, 2016.
May 11, 2016
-
Veterans' Health Care:
Proper Plan Needed to Modernize System for Paying Community ProvidersGAO-16-353: Published: May 11, 2016. Publicly Released: May 11, 2016.
Looking for more? Browse all our products here