Civil Penalty Fund

When a person or company violates a federal consumer financial protection law, the Bureau can bring an enforcement proceeding against them. If that person or company is found to have violated the law, it may have to pay a civil penalty, also known as a civil money penalty. When the Bureau collects civil penalties, it deposits them in the Civil Penalty Fund. The Fund was established by the Dodd-Frank Wall Street Reform and Consumer Protection Act of 2010.

The Bureau will use the money in the Civil Penalty Fund to provide some compensation to consumers who were harmed by violations of federal consumer financial law for which civil penalties were imposed. To the extent that victims cannot be located or it is otherwise not practicable to pay victims, the Bureau may use money in the Fund for consumer education and financial literacy programs. The Bureau has issued a Civil Penalty Fund rule that specifically governs how the Bureau uses the money in the Civil Penalty Fund.

The Bureau issued a rule to inform the public about how it will use the money in the Civil Penalty Fund. The Bureau also published a notice of proposed rulemaking (NPRM) to seek public input on the Civil Penalty Fund rule and ways that the Bureau could improve the rule in the future.

The Civil Penalty Fund rule became effective on May 7, 2013.

The rule governs how the Bureau uses money in the Civil Penalty Fund. The rule:

1. Provides that the Bureau will designate a Fund Administrator who will manage the Civil Penalty Fund in accordance with the rule.
2. Explains the conditions under which victims may receive payments from the Fund and the amounts that those payments may be.
3. Establishes procedures that the Fund Administrator will follow to decide how money in the Fund will be allocated, both to classes of victims and for consumer education and financial literacy programs.
4. Explains how payments will be distributed to victims.
5. Requires the Fund Administrator to issue regular reports on how money in the Civil Penalty Fund has been used.

The Civil Penalty Fund Administrator manages the Fund. The Fund Administrator reports to the Chief Financial Officer. 

The Civil Penalty Fund Governance Board is chaired by the Bureau’s Chief of Staff and includes the Associate Director for Supervision, Enforcement, Fair Lending & Equal Opportunity; the Associate Director for Consumer Education & Engagement; the Chief Operating Officer; and the General Counsel. 

All civil penalties are deposited into the Civil Penalty Fund, where they are pooled and can be used for payments to any eligible victim. Victims are not limited to receiving only what the person or company that harmed them paid into the Fund.

The Bureau may make Civil Penalty Fund payments to consumers who were harmed by a violation for which civil penalties were imposed and who aren’t otherwise expected to get full compensation for their compensable harm, as described by the rule. The Bureau hopes to make payments to all such victims, but whether it will be able to will depend on the amount of money in the Fund and other factors. 

 Every six months, the Fund Administrator will determine which classes of victims will receive payments from the Fund. To make that determination, the Fund Administrator will assess how much money is available in the Fund and will review closed cases to determine which victims are eligible to receive payments. The Fund Administrator will then follow the procedures established in the rule to allocate funds to “classes” of victims—that is, to groups of victims from a case that suffered from the same kind of violation. Once funds are allocated to a class of victims, we will begin the process of distributing payments to victims in that class.

In accordance with the Civil Penalty Fund rule, the Bureau allocated the following amounts to the eligible classes of victims in the following cases and to consumer education and financial literacy programs:

May 30, 2013 

Payday Loan Debt Solution, Inc.  $488,815 

Gordon, et al.  $10,000,000 

Consumer Education and Financial Literacy Programs  $13,380,000 

November 29, 2013

American Debt Settlement Solutions, Inc.  $499,248 

National Legal Help Center, Inc.  $2,057,983 

May 30, 2014

Meracord LLC  $11,542,229 

3-D Resorts–Bluegrass, LLC.  $6,704,100 

November 29, 2014

Culver Capital, LLC  $3,400,434 

Amerisave Mortgage Corporation  $1,380,470 

Global Client Solutions, LLC  $107,995,400 

May 29, 2015

College Education Services LLC  $3,459,336 

Union Workers Credit Services, Inc.  $18,908,744 

National Corrective Group, Inc.  $23,262,067 

Culver Capital, LLC  $421,481 

November 27, 2015

Hoffman Law Group f/k/a Residential Litigation $11,074,842 

Student Financial Aid Services, Inc.  $9,300,000 

Consumer Education and Financial Literacy Programs  $15,432,809 

May 27, 2016

Morgan Drexen, Inc. and Walter Ledda  $98,889,115

Irvine Web Works, Inc. d/b/a Student Loan Processing  $7,923,548

Student Aid Institute, Steven Lamont  $3,508,900

November 29, 2016

Morgan Drexen, Inc. and Walter Ledda  $33,993,373

May 30, 2017

Orion Processing, LLC, d/b/a World Law Processing, et al. $98,408,416

Siringoringo et al. $20,825,000

Global Client Solutions $8,188,668

November 29, 2017

The Mortgage Law Group, LLP $18,331,737

Commercial Credit Consultants, et al. $21,500,716

Prime Marketing Holdings, LLC $14,451,033

May 18, 2018

Commercial Credit Consultants, et al.  $9,149,286

Prime Marketing Holdings, LLC  $6,149,407

Please refer to our list of payments to harmed consumers by case to find out which distributions are currently in process. Click on the case name for information on who to contact about whether you’ll receive a payment. If the case that affected you is not listed on that page, the distribution process for your case has not yet begun. Please check back for updates in the future.

The total of all Civil Penalty Fund deposits through Sept. 30, 2017, is $566 million. 

Under the rule, victims may receive up to the amount of their uncompensated harm from the Fund. The rule describes what will constitute victims’ “uncompensated harm” for purposes of payment from the Civil Penalty Fund. The Civil Penalty Fund is not intended as a complete replacement for other sources of compensation. Depending on the circumstances of a case, the amount that the Bureau might pay from the Fund may provide only partial compensation for the full scope of victims’ harm. The amount that victims will actually receive will depend on how much money is in the Fund and other factors.

To determine the amount of a victim’s uncompensated harm, the Fund Administrator will take the victim’s total compensable harm, and subtract out any compensation that the victim has received—or is reasonably expected to receive—for that harm. The Fund Administrator will determine the victim’s total compensable harm by looking to the terms of the relevant court or administrative order. If the amount of a victim’s compensable harm cannot be determined based on the terms of the relevant order, the victim’s compensable harm generally will be his or her out-of-pocket losses that resulted from the violation.

The rule establishes procedures that the Fund Administrator will follow to decide how much money victims will receive. If there is enough money available, the Fund Administrator generally will allocate funds so as to give all eligible victims full compensation for their uncompensated harm, as described in the rule. The rule also establishes procedures for the Fund Administrator to follow if there isn’t enough money available in the Fund to compensate everyone fully.

Allocating funds means setting aside money for a specific purpose. For purposes of the Civil Penalty Fund, the Fund Administrator “allocates” funds when she sets aside money from the Civil Penalty Fund for payments to particular classes of victims, or for use on consumer education and financial literacy programs.

Under the rule, the Fund Administrator will decide how to use money in the Fund every six months. In particular, every six months, the Fund Administrator will allocate funds to particular classes of victims and, if appropriate, for consumer education and financial literacy programs. The Fund Administrator has posted a schedule on consumerfinance.gov that shows when these allocations will occur. Under the current schedule, allocations are made between April 1 and May 30, and between October 1 and November 29 of each year. 

Once the Fund Administrator allocates funds to a class of victims, the Bureau will begin the process of distributing payments to the victims in that class. That process includes identifying and locating the victims in the class. When the first payments will be distributed to individual victims will depend on how long that process takes. The Bureau is working with its third-party administrators to distribute payments to eligible victims in classes from cases to which funds have been allocated. Please refer to the table at the bottom of this webpage, for a list of cases currently in distribution.

If there is more than enough money in the Civil Penalty Fund to compensate fully all eligible victims’ uncompensated harm, the Bureau generally will first provide full compensation to all eligible victims to the extent practicable. Then, it may allocate remaining funds for consumer education and financial literacy programs, and/or it may keep money in the Fund for future victims. 

If, at the time of a scheduled allocation, there is not enough money available in the Civil Penalty Fund to provide full compensation for all eligible victims’ uncompensated harm, the Fund Administrator will allocate funds equitably among the classes of victims from the most recent six-month period, who have not yet had an opportunity to receive an allocation from the Fund. The Fund Administrator will then allocate funds to classes of victims from preceding six-month periods if funds remain. If there is not enough money to give full compensation to all eligible victims who could practicably be paid, no money will be allocated for consumer education and financial literacy programs.

Every six months, the Fund Administrator will decide how much money, if any, to allocate for consumer education and financial literacy programs. The first priority will always be to allocate funds for payments to victims. However, if funds remain after allocating enough money to provide full compensation to all eligible victims who can practicably be paid, the Fund Administrator may allocate some or all of those remaining funds for consumer education and financial literacy programs.

The Bureau has adopted a set of criteria for selecting programs that will serve consumers and improve consumer education and financial literacy. The criteria require, among other things, that programs further the Bureau’s mission and strategic goals; promote or enhance financial literacy and consumers’ economic security; and include specific outcome targets to ensure the programs’ effectiveness. 

The Bureau has selected the first consumer education and financial literacy program funded with Civil Penalty Fund money. The Bureau has deployed a financial coaching program that will serve two groups of Americans: (1) recent veterans who are transitioning from service member to veteran life, as well as military widows and widowers, and (2) economically vulnerable consumers who want to improve their approach to money management. The Bureau has contracted with Armed Forces Services Corporation to run this program. 

One-on-one financial coaching will help veterans transition from military to civilian financial life, and help consumers who may be cash-strapped learn how to manage the money that they have more effectively to achieve their financial goals. Working with a financial coach can also help consumers identify and understand how to distinguish between useful financial products and frauds and scams, thus safeguarding against them becoming victims of frauds and scams in the future. The program for recent veterans and military spouse survivors is planned to have a presence in all fifty states. The component for economically vulnerable consumers, although smaller, will provide financial coaching services through locations that are diverse in terms of geographic location, and include those from urban and rural communities, and from different cultural, ethnic, racial, and other backgrounds.

The Bureau uses the federal procurement process for these programs and posts information about the process and contract requirements as Civil Penalty Fund money becomes available for consumer education and financial literacy programs. 

The Civil Penalty Fund is maintained at the Federal Reserve Bank of New York in a noninterest-bearing account. 

The Fund Administrator, a position in the Office of the Chief Financial Officer, will maintain responsibility for allocating and distributing funds from the Civil Penalty Fund. The Bureau has contracted with two third-party administrators to assist the Fund Administrator with administrative aspects of distributing payments to victims. 

When the Bureau enforces the law, it or a court may order the person or company that violated the law to take action to remedy the harm it caused consumers. This can include requiring the person or company to compensate its victims for this harm. This compensation is generally called “redress.” In some cases, the Bureau may require the person or company that violated the law to pay the redress directly to consumers. And in other cases the Bureau may require the person or company to pay the redress to the Bureau, and the Bureau will then distribute the redress money to the victims of that person or company’s violations. 

Civil money penalties and payments to victims from the Civil Penalty Fund are different. When a person or company that violated the law is ordered to pay a civil penalty, that penalty does not go directly to that person’s or company’s victims, but rather is put in the Civil Penalty Fund. All civil penalties that anyone pays to the Bureau are pooled in this common Fund. Money in the Civil Penalty Fund then may be used to pay any eligible victim in accordance with the Civil Penalty Fund rule. 

The main difference between redress and Civil Penalty Fund payments is the link between who pays the money and who receives the money. When a person or company pays redress, that redress money can go only to victims of that person or company. When a person or company pays a civil penalty, that money goes into the Civil Penalty Fund and can be used to pay any eligible victim from any case.