|
|
NATIONAL INSTITUTE ON ALCOHOL ABUSE AND ALCOHOLISM Report of a Subcommittee of the National Advisory Council
on Alcohol Abuse and May 11-13, 1998 U.S. Department of Health and Human Services
TABLE OF CONTENTS NEUROSCIENCE AND BEHAVIOR PROGRAM Training and Career Development MOLECULAR AND CELLULAR
EFFECTS OF ALCOHOL Neurotransmission Lipid/Protein Interactions Program Portfolio Neuroendocrine Program Portfolio Molecular and Cellular Adaptive Responses to Chronic Ethanol Exposure Neuroadaptation
Program Portfolio ADDICTION AND OTHER BEHAVIORS
IN ANIMAL MODELS Neuroadaptive Behavioral Effects Adolescent Period Program Portfolio STUDIES OF ACUTE AND
CHRONIC EFFECTS OF ALCOHOL IN HUMANS Mechanisms of Alcoholic Behaviors Human Neuroendocrine Studies Sleep Studies Program Portfolio COGNITIVE/BEHAVIORAL/STRUCTURAL
DEFICITS Neuroimaging Studies Neurophysiological Studies Program Portfolio B: Experts in Neuroscience and Behavior C: NIAAA Program Staff D: NIAAA Staff, Representatives from other NIH Institutes, and Guests NEUROSCIENCE AND BEHAVIOR REPORT OF A SUBCOMMITTEE OF THE NATIONAL ADVISORY COUNCIL ON ALCOHOL ABUSE AND ALCOHOLISM EXECUTIVE SUMMARY The National Institute on Alcohol Abuse and Alcoholism's (NIAAA) Subcommittee for the Review of the Extramural Research Portfolio for Neuroscience and Behavior met on 11-13 May 1998. The charge to the Subcommittee was to examine the appropriateness of the breadth, coverage, and balance of the neuroscience and behavior research portfolio, identifying research areas that are well covered and others which are either under-investigated or which otherwise warrant significantly increased attention. The Subcommittee was asked also to provide specific advice and guidance on the scope and direction of the Institute's extramural research activities in the neuroscience and behavior area. The Subcommittee for the Review of the Extramural Research Portfolio for Neuroscience and Behavior consisted of two NIAAA Advisory Council co-chairs and an advisory group of 18 individuals. Fifteen of these individuals have demonstrated expertise in alcohol-related areas and three individuals have demonstrated expertise in non-alcohol-related areas (see Appendix A). The review process was initiated by having experts (see Appendix B) in neuroscience and behavior prepare written assessments of the state of knowledge, gaps in knowledge, and research opportunities. NIAAA program staff (see Appendix C) presented the current extramural portfolio, categorized into the areas of basic neuroscience research, molecular adaptive responses, neuroendocrine system, studies of the acute and chronic effects of alcohol in animals and in humans, cognitive/behavioral/structural deficits in humans, and training and career development. All information was shared with experts, selected NIAAA staff, and the co-chairs and advisory group before the meeting. A summary of FY97 awards in neuroscience and behavior is detailed below.
*Seven of 14 centers have neuroscience and behavior components; five of these estimate > 50% is invested in neuroscience and behavior. NIAAA Neuroscience and Behavior Awards
On 11-13 May 1998, experts and NIAAA program staff made abbreviated presentations of their material followed by discussion among all of the participants, including representatives from other NIH Institutes and guests (see Appendix D). After completing this process, the co-chairs and advisory group, with input from the experts, delineated the following list of research priorities, in order of importance. PRIORITIES RESULTING FROM REVIEW OF NEUROSCIENCE AND BEHAVIOR PORTFOLIO
These areas of importance were derived from a list of 22. The remaining 14 are listed by topic without regard to priority. General Considerations
Molecular/Cellular
Animal Models
Human Studies
Additional gaps in knowledge and research opportunities were determined by experts in each of the areas covered and are listed in the text of the report. Back to Top(Walter A. Hunt, Ph.D.) This overview will provide information on overall programmatic balance of the portfolio, with all analyses based on awards made in FY97. Specific aspects of the portfolio will be presented in other reports. The overall portfolio currently consists of 121 grants at a total cost of $21,677,142. The balance of neuroscience grants to behavior grants is almost equal. Most of the research funded is basic research, with very little of the portfolio considered applied research. Those few grants that are applied research relate to the development of medications at the preclinical or early clinical level. About 80% of the grants, representing 77% of the awards, used animals and 20% used humans, representing 23% of the awards. About 70% of the grants were in vivo studies, representing 68% of the awards. Animal and human studies represent 62% of the grants, with molecular and cellular studies reflecting the remainder in approximately equal amounts. The following list of priorities represents common themes among various initiatives.
The last recommendation evolves from the need to translate basic research findings into clinical applications. To that end, a Medications Development Working Group was recently formed to determine if research findings from basic preclinical work could provide a basis for developing potential agents for clinical trials to treat alcoholism. A short-term goal is a workshop to bring together individuals from academia, industry, and government to build bridges among the groups, review the process by which compounds are developed into drugs for clinical trials, and solicit ideas about how NIAAA can help facilitate this process. Back to TopTRAINING AND CAREER DEVELOPMENT PROGRAMS IN NEUROSCIENCE
AND BEHAVIORAL RESEARCH Training of new investigators is supported through several mechanisms, depending on the educational level and experience of the applicant. Much of the program is based on individual fellowships and training grants. The remainder of the program supports scientist development awards at different levels of experience. Overall Training Program Forty-six competitive and noncompetitive awards were funded in FY97. Of those, 19 were individual fellowships, 10 were training grants, and 17 were scientist development awards. Thirty awards supported neuroscience research and 16 supported behavioral research. Individual Fellowships: The balance between predoctoral and postdoctoral awards is fairly even, with a slightly greater number for predoctoral awards. Based on NIH policy, the commitment to individual fellowships relative to training grants should be at least 15% of the available funds. In FY97, the figure for NIAAA was 19%. Only one of the awards is for a potential clinical researcher. Four involve neurotransmitter receptors, three use genetic approaches, two study ontogenetic differences in the effects of alcohol, three examine the motivational effects of alcohol, four on the central control of alcohol reinforcement, one on stress and neurosteroids, and two are minority predoctoral fellowships. Training Grants: The ten training grants support 55 slots for 21 predoctoral and 34 postdoctoral trainees. The relative balance between neuroscience training slots and behavioral training slots is 26 to 31. Three grants educate trainees in using genetic approaches to discover the mechanisms underlying actions of alcohol on the brain, four deal with basic neurochemical mechanisms, two with neurotoxic actions of alcohol, one with brain imaging, and three with behavioral studies. Two training grants primarily use human subjects. Scientist Development Awards: Of the 14 grants, most were mentored awards, and almost half were to junior, mentored investigators. All of the mentored awards support investigators in neuroscience research. Only two awards support investigators in clinical research. Most of the these investigators study basic actions of alcohol on neurotransmitter receptors or signal transduction systems. Two grants have behavioral components. Recruitment and Future Directions Recruiting efforts involve staff contacts with potential applicants at scientific meetings. In addition, site visits of NIAAA-funded training grants were undertaken to introduce trainees to the grant process and inform them about the benefits of individual fellowships and mentored scientist development awards. These visits resulted in increased applications but have been discontinued because of limited travel funds. The training programs are fairly mature, with most mechanisms of training adequately represented. However, increased training of clinical investigators could provide an additional pool of needed scientists to pursue alcohol research with human subjects. Back to Top
MOLECULAR AND CELLULAR EFFECTS OF ALCOHOL Acute Actions of Ethanol on Specific neural Targets NEUROTRANSMISSION: RECEPTORS, TRANSPORTERS, MODULATORS, ION CHANNELS AND SIGNAL TRANSDUCTION Gaps in Knowledge and Research Opportunities (David M. Lovinger, Ph.D.)
LIPID INVOLVEMENT IN THE ACUTE ACTIONS OF ETHANOL IN THE NERVOUS SYSTEM Gaps in Knowledge and Research Opportunities (Steven N. Treistman, Ph.D.)
a) target protein of known behavioral or physiological relevance to alcohol action should be selected; b) effects of lipid perturbation and possibly modulation of lipid composition on the protein in its native environments should be determined; c) target protein should be capable of being reconstituted into a simplified lipid environment for examining alcohol effects; d) selection of a cloned protein permits expression studies in a variety of native membranes and enables mutagenesis studies. Continue to study the significant role of lipids in the compensatory responses of cells exposed to alcohol. Back to TopNIAAA BASIC NEUROSCIENCE RESEARCH PORTFOLIO In FY97, the NIAAA Basic Neuroscience Research Program funded 35 extramural grants for a total of $5.5 million. Of these, 30 were basic research project grants, and five were career development awards. This program supports a wide variety of investigations that explore different effects of alcohol on the brain at multiple levels of analysis and employ a number of different neuroscience techniques. Several different molecular targets are being examined, as are different mechanisms hypothesized to underlie the actions of alcohol in the brain.
Grant Distribution by Level of Analysis
s
Grant Distribution by Molecular Targets of Alcohol
Grant Distribution by Studies of Brain Regions
Molecular Level Alcohol, unlike most other highly abused substances, does not act on a single specific target in the brain. Instead, it interacts with many targets, such as neurotransmitter receptors and voltage-gated ion channels on nerve cells. A major challenge confronting molecular studies is the lack of uniform effects of alcohol on various cell types in different regions in the brain. Several complementary working hypotheses address the cellular and regional specificity of alcohol. The first postulates that alcohol directly interacts with specific amino-acid residues or domains of the target proteins. The second proposes that expressions of particular receptor subunit combinations contribute to the different degrees of alcohol sensitivity in different neurons. A more recent hypothesis suggests that post-translational modifications, such as the phosphorylation status of a target protein, can determine sensitivity to alcohol. Direct molecular Action Sites (8 grants) The majority of research projects within this category are attempting to identify the sites of alcohol action on target molecules, including voltage-gated CA++ and K+ channels and ACh, GABAA, NMDA, and glycine receptors. One working hypothesis is that alcohol alters channel kinetics, such as channel open time, channel closing time, and desensitization status of molecular targets. Other investigators study protein targets in their native environments. The vast majority use a combination of electrophysiological and molecular biological approaches to test alcohol effects on recombinant proteins expressed in Xenopus oocytes or transfected mammalian cell lines. Two research groups introduced a state-of-the-art approach - the chimeric receptor technique - to alcohol research. Chimeric receptors consist of complementary parts of two target proteins that give opposite responses to alcohol. By using a well-designed set of chimeras, the process of locating the sites of action can be significantly accelerated. There has been a long debate over the question of whether lipid, protein, or the interface between them is the site of action of alcohol. Although increasing evidence suggests that membrane proteins are the direct targets, the role of the lipid environment in mediating effects of alcohol is likely to be important. Two projects are attempting to further clarify this challenging and confusing issue. Both projects use preparations that incorporate well-characterized protein candidates into a lipid bilayer. In this environment, each lipid component is known and can be individually manipulated. Subunit Composition (8 grants) Both voltage-fated and ligand-gated channel proteins are composed of multiple subunits. The putative molecular structure of the superfamily of ligand-gated channels/neurotransmitter receptors is a pentamer consisting of five either identical or distinct subunits. It is evident that the number of possible combinations of subunits is quite large. In addition, an individual neuron can express multiple types of a given receptor, based on the combination of different subunits. When considering the many different regions in the brain, the patterns of expression of those subunit compositions can be exceedingly complex. Currently, eight research groups supported by this program are testing the "subunit composition" hypothesis. The two major approaches that are investigating the structure-function relationship use either a) recombinant proteins produced in various expression systems or b) natural proteins expressed in intact neurons. Several research groups are taking advantage of some of the newest pharmacological tools. The binding selectivity to subunits of these agonists or antagonists appears to correlate with alcohol specificity of certain subunits. Other investigators are using different approaches, such as specific antibodies against the candidate subunits. A novel technique - the single cell RT-PCR method - has recently been introduced to alcohol research. This sophisticated method, when properly used, can identify the profile of the subunits at the mRNA level in an identified cell. Protein Modifications (2 grants) Previous observations suggest that phosphorylation/dephosphorylation status of some target proteins, such as GABAA, NMDA, and 5-HT3 receptors, might be important for understanding the interactions between alcohol and these targets. Two research projects are exploring this hypothesis by applying a combination of electrophysiological, biochemical, and molecular biological techniques on recombinant receptors. Cellular Level (7 grants) Two projects are examining the effects of alcohol at the single cell level. One project is using the brain slice preparation and electrophysiological recording techniques to study the acute effects of alcohol. A second study is using both brain slice and in vivo preparations to explore the chronic effects of alcohol on the spontaneous activity of dopaminergic cells in the ventral tegmental area (VTA). Most projects are focused at the synaptic level. For example, one investigator is using an in vitro NMDA synapse model to identify cellular mechanisms underlying the development of acute tolerance to alcohol. Another investigator is using both traditional and organotypic slice preparations to explore the alteration of voltage-gated Ca++ channels following acute and chronic alcohol exposure. Several projects are investigating the effects of alcohol on synaptic plasticity. One project is testing the hypothesis that subcortical inputs to the dentate gyrus mediate the acute actions of alcohol on both short- and long-term plasticity in hippocampus. Another project is exploring a possible role for the amygdala in mediating the acute effects of alcohol on synaptic plasticity. One study uses hippocampal activity-related spatial memory as a model system to test the effects of alcohol on different age groups of animals. Neural Circuitry Level (3 grants) Research at the neural circuitry level has not yet been intensively studied. Investigators supported by this program have recently developed several novel methods that are further extensions of the traditional extracellular single-unit recording techniques. One uses a multi-electrode, single-unit recording apparatus that can perform simultaneous recordings of neuronal activities from different areas of a defined neural circuit during a specific behavioral paradigm. This allows the analysis of spatial/temporal pattern changes of neuronal firing related to alcohol-induced behaviors. Another new method combines in vivo microdialysis with electro-physiological and behavioral techniques. This provides a means of locally delivering alcohol and other pharmacological agents to individual neurons, simultaneously recording neuronal activity, and collecting neurotransmitters released from the same neuron in real-time, during ongoing behaviors. Recommendations Molecular Level Direct Action Sites
Subunit Composition
-single cell RT-PCR -subunit-specific antibodies;
-antisense techniques -inducible knockout, tissue-specific knockout techniques. Protein Modifications
Cellular Level
Neural Circuitry Level
EFFECTS OF ALCOHOL ON THE NEUROENDOCRINE SYSTEM Gaps in Knowledge and Research Opportunities (Catherine Rivier, Ph.D.)
ALCOHOL AND THE NEUROENDOCRINE SYSTEM In FY97, the neuroendocrine portfolio consisted of 14 grants totaling $2.1 million. With the exception of one human study, all remaining 13 grants study alcohol effects on the endocrine system using experimental animals. Of the 14 grants, five focus on the Hypothalamic-Pituitary-Adrenal (HPA) axis, five on the Hypothalamic-Pituitary-Gonadal (HPG) axis, two on the endocrine regulation of immune function, one on hormonal regulation of alcohol metabolism, and one on enkephalin gene expression. Twelve of the 14 grants are categorized as basic research while the remaining two are considered applied research. Two grants focus on response to stress, and all 14 grants study alcohol at the cellular and molecular level. Studies on the HPA Axis (5 grants) Alcohol and Stress: Interactive Effects Prenatal ethanol exposure elicits HPA axis hyper-responsiveness and compromises immune integrity in adult male and female rats. Alcohol-Interleukin Interactions on the HPA Axis Prenatal exposure to alcohol perturbs HPA esponsiveness to interleukin-1 beta by blunting the ACTH response in immature (3 week) male and female rats, but conversely produces a potentiating effect when these same animals reach adulthood. Alcohol Effects on Opiomelanocortinergic Regulation Under non-stressful conditions, moderately high BALs temporarily activate the HPA axis, with concomitant activation of the forebrain opiomelanocortinergic neuronal system. HPA Axis and Alcoholism The HPA dynamics is different in nonalcoholic people with a family history of alcoholism (FHP) versus nonalcoholic subjects without a family history of alcoholism (FHN). Alcohol and Neuroendocrine Function - Oxytocin Expression Alcohol inhibits the secretion of oxytocin which may play a role in the development of tolerance to alcohol. Oxytocin secretion is reduced during acute intoxication, but not during alcohol withdrawal. Chronic alcohol administration inhibited oxytocin secretion in male, but not female rats. Studies on the HPG Axis (5 grants) Pubertal Alcohol is Disruptive to Male Reproduction Acute alcohol administration to 35-day-old (prepubertal), 45-day-old (mid pubertal), or 55-day-old (late pubertal) male rats caused depression of testosterone and luteinizing hormone (LH) levels in the two older groups; Naltrexone co-administered reversed the testosterone, but not the LH depression. Chronic alcohol administration to male rats (45 and 55 days old) that were subcutaneously implanted with a pellet of Naltrexone two days before being offered a liquid diet containing ethanol (36% of total calories) for 14 days showed similar effects. Alcohol Testicular Effects Alcohol decreased testosterone secretion and testicular interstitial fluid formation in rats. This effect is not mediated by endogenous opioids or nitric oxide. Ethanol and Female Rodent Reproduction A single dose of ethanol given to female rats nearly obliterated serum proestrum LH levels, and serum estradiol and progesterone levels fell to half of the control values. Neuroendocrine Effects of Alcohol on Puberty In vivo and in vitro investigations have demonstrated that insulin-like growth factor-1 (IGF-1) is crucial to the onset of puberty in females, and that ethanol impedes the physiological responses of the brain and ovary to IGF-1. Ethanol-induced depression of LH release arises from a decrease in prostaglandin E2 formation. Leptin also induces the prepubertal release of LH; peripherally administered leptin reverses the depressed LH secretion by ethanol. Alcohol also perturbs the nitric oxide/nitric oxide synthase (NO/NOS) system at specific phases of the reproductive cycle during puberty, consistent with a role in ovulation and luteal formation. Alcohol and Hyperprolactinemia The human disorder, gynecomastia, observed in some alcoholic men, and which arises from elevated plasma levels of the pituitary prolactin hormone (PRL) is being studied in a rat model. Studies focus on elucidating the cellular mechanisms (presumptively involving inhibition of TGF-B1 in the pituitary) of hyperprolactinemia. Studies on Endocrine Regulation of Immune Function (2 grants) Immunosuppression in a Binge-Drinking Model A single high dose of ethanol in the mouse produces peak corticosterone levels reaching 10-times basal levels. Humoral immune function was suppressed, expression of IL-1B, IL-2, and IL-4 were compromised in the spleen, and resident B-cell population was reduced. RU486 (a glucocorticoid antagonist) reversed the suppressed antibody and cytokine responses. Exogenous administration of corticosterone mimicked some, but not all, of the effects produced by a high dose of ethanol, suggesting that additional components are contributing to the immunosuppression produced by high-dose ethanol administration. Natural Killer (NK) Cells and Binge-Drinking Ethanol suppresses basal and induced NK cell activity. The suppressed NK activity arises partly via a glucocorticoid-based mechanism, and partly to the perturbation of the balance between Th1 and Th2 cells. Studies on Endocrine Regulation of Ethanol Metabolism (1 grant) Dihydrotestosterone (DHT) suppresses ADH transcription in hepatocytes, possibly explaining the higher ethanol elimination rates in women. The suppression of rat liver ADH activity by DHT was associated with a decrease in ADH protein. Studies on the Effects of Ethanol on Enkephalin Gene Expression (1 grant) The ultimate goal of this grant is to study the role of enkephalins in alcohol-seeking behavior. The immediate focus is on the mechanism by which members of the steroid-retinoid receptor superfamily modulate expression of the preproenkephalin gene. Recommendations More research is encouraged in the following areas:
Molecular and Cellular Adaptive Responses to Chronic Ethanol Exposure NEUROADAPTATION Gaps in Knowledge and Research Opportunities (Paula L. Hoffman, Ph.D., A. Leslie Morrow, Ph.D., Tamara Phillips, Ph.D., and George R. Siggins, Ph.D.)
NEUROTOXICITY Gaps in Knowledge and Research Opportunities (Fulton T. Crews, Ph.D.)
PROGRAM IN MOLECULAR NEUROPHARMACOLOGY In order to identify the primary effects of chronic alcohol exposure, investigators studying neuroadaptation and neurotoxicity have examined alcohol-induced molecular changes in cellular components. Some of these studies can be performed in intact animals, thereby permitting correlation with alcohol-induced changes in systemic neural function and behavior. Other studies can be performed only in cultured cells. While studies in cultured cells provide information about some molecular processes that can't be assayed in intact animals, it is often difficult to evaluate their behavioral significance. Moreover, for some measures that can be made both in cultured cells and whole animals, different changes are observed in these two experimental systems. For this reason, many investigators try to confirm cellular observations in intact animals whenever possible. Withdrawal NIAAA supports a number of studies, most of them in intact animals, of molecular changes associated with withdrawal from chronic alcohol exposure. The largest group of these studies is directed at GABAA receptors, focusing on changes in brain-regional distribution and pharmacological properties (including interactions with neurosteroids), and the underlying causes of such changes. The second largest group of studies focuses on similar issues related to NMDA receptors. Other studies examine 5-HT receptors and their downstream signaling (especially their relationship to anxiety during withdrawal), non-NMDA glutamate receptors, fos-like immunoreactivity, mechanism of upregulation of voltage-gated Ca++ channels, and free radical accumulation due to oxidative stress. Of the 11 projects in this category, four include studies on cultured cells. Tolerance NIAAA supports studies of a variety of molecular changes induced by chronic alcohol exposure in various types of neuronal cell lines. While the precise relationships of these changes to alcohol-induced physiological changes in animals are not yet understood, they could potentially be related to tolerance or dependence. These studies include heterologous desensitization of signaling from purine receptors, intracellular translocation of protein kinase A, global changes in gene expression, and the normal physiological role of a phosducin-like protein, whose levels are raised in response to chronic alcohol exposure. Neurotoxicity Most of the studies of molecular changes associated with neurotoxicity involve a combination of experiments on both intact animals and culture cells. The largest group of such studies focuses on alcohol-induced changes in brain-regional distribution of neurotrophic factors and their receptors, the role of neurotrophic factors in protection from alcohol-induced disruption of calcium homeostasis, and the mechanism of enhancement of neurotrophin-induced neurite outgrowth by alcohol. The second largest group of studies is directed at NMDA receptors, focusing on changes in brain-regional distribution and pharmacological properties, underlying causes of such changes, and changes in downstream signaling (especially induction of nitric oxide synthase). A small group of studies is concerned with alcohol's enhancement of pro-oxidant-induced membrane lipid peroxidation and changes in gene expression. Finally, individual projects study, variously, the mechanisms of alcohol-induced changes in the levels and/or activities of the Na-Ca exchanger and metabotropic glutamate receptors. Molecular Neuropharmacology (FY97)
Recommendations The projects described above study molecular changes induced by alcohol in intact animals and/or cultured cells. Alcohol-induced molecular changes can be correlated with behavioral and physiological changes in animals, whereas molecular changes in cultured cells cannot be directly correlated. Investigators typically hypothesize that the molecular changes they observe actually mediate particular behavioral and physiological changes. Since chronic alcohol exposure induces a multitude of molecular, physiological, and behavioral changes, correlative evidence is insufficient to prove that a particular molecular changes mediates a particular physiological or behavioral change. Emphasis should be placed on experiments in which an investigator specifically blocks either the alcohol-induced molecular change under study, or the function of the molecule whose disposition is changed by alcohol, and then observes whether this intervention also blocks the behavioral change under study. Alternatively, the investigator can induce the molecular change by some means other than alcohol treatment, and observe whether the behavioral or physiological change still occurs. Only about one fifth of the projects described above attempt to perform such an intervention. Back to TopADDICTION AND OTHER BEHAVIORS IN ANIMAL MODELS BASIC BEHAVIORAL EFFECTS AND UNDERLYING Gaps in Knowledge and Research Opportunities (Kathleen A. Grant, Ph.D.)
NEUROADAPTIVE CHANGES IN NEUROTRANSMITTER SYSTEMS MEDIATING ALCOHOL-INDUCED BEHAVIORS Gaps in Knowledge and Research Opportunities (Friedbert Weiss, Ph.D.)
ADOLESCENT PERIOD: BIOLOGICAL BASIS OF VULNERABILITY TO DEVELOP ALCOHOLISM AND OTHER ALCOHOL-MEDIATED BEHAVIORS pportunities (Linda P. Spear, Ph.D.)
STUDIES OF THE ADDICTION PROCESS AND OTHER BEHAVIORS IN ANIMAL MODELS(Ellen D. Witt, Ph.D.) Animal studies, representing about $6 million, are focussed largely on neural mechanisms of sensitization, tolerance, dependence, withdrawal, relapse, and more recently the reinforcing and hedonic effects of alcohol that can lead to alcohol-seeking behavior and excessive drinking. Animal models have also been constructed to study innate neural and behavioral traits as well as the acute and chronic effects of alcohol on behaviors such as learning, memory, and aggression. The animal portfolio has been divided conceptually into five broad scientific categories. Category No. of Grants FY97
Basic Behavioral Effects and Underlying Neural Circuitry with Limited Alcohol Exposure (Low to Moderate/Non-dependent)
1. Alcohol-Seeking Behavior/Hedonic Effects, Neural Circuitry, Neurotransmitters Self-Administration: Operant Reinforcement, Two Bottle Choice (7 grants) Seven grants are investigating the neural circuitry and neurotransmitter pathways underlying excessive alcohol drinking using either operant self-administration paradigms or two-bottle choice. All seven grants use micro injection and/or microdialysis techniques to look at the regulation of the oral self-administration by various neurotransmitter systems in specific regions of the cortico-mesolimbic reward pathway. Drug Discrimination (4 grants) Four grants are investigating multiple receptor mechanisms that mediate the discriminative stimulus effects of ethanol, i.e., the internal subjective effects that are reinforcing and maintain drinking. Brain Stimulation Reward (2 grants) Reductions in brain stimulation reward thresholds are used to identify brain areas that mediate reinforcement after drug administration using selected lines of alcohol-preferring rats. Plus Maze (2 grants) The Plus Maze is used to measure alcohol's anxiolytic effects in selected lines of alcohol preferring/nonpreferring rats. Place Preference, Taste Aversion (3 grants) Three grants are studying the neural circuits and/or neurotransmitter systems mediating the hedonic or aversive properties of initial alcohol exposure using place and taste conditioning paradigms. 2. Tolerance/Acute Withdrawal Place Preference/Aversion, Operant Self-Administration, Drug Discrimination ( 2 grants) One grant is investigating whether ethanol's aversive effects are reduced and its hedonic effects are enhanced as tolerance develops to ethanol's hypothermic effects. A second project is investigating acute withdrawal 12-30 hours after a single high dose of ethanol, referred to as "ethanol delayed effect" (EDE) or hangover, and determining whether physiological and subjective effects of EDE are similar to phase shift effects associated with jet-lag or work shifts. 3. Environmental Factors, Taste, Gender Operant Self-Administration (6 grants) Many social and environmental factors such as stress (social status), schedules of reinforcement, taste factors, and temperature influence the establishment of alcohol-seeking behavior. Four studies are investigating environmental factors in an operant reinforcement paradigm to evaluate reinforcing efficacy of ethanol alone or multiple reinforcers that differ in taste (ethanol vs. sucrose or ethanol vs. ethanol/sucrose). Two grants are examining gender differences, hormonal regulation, and effects of social status on operant self-administration of ethanol. One study is investigating the role of ambient temperature in altering ethanol's hedonic effects as measured by taste and place conditioning and self-administration. Conditioned Stimuli, Incentive Motivation (3 grants) Previously neutral environmental stimuli can acquire motivational properties of a primary reinforcer (alcohol) that contribute to alcohol-seeking. These grants are examining the role of conditioned stimuli (previously neutral stimuli paired with alcohol) in reinstating or maintaining alcohol self-administration following extinction. 4. Acute/Chronic Brain and Behavioral Effects (4 grants) Four grants are investigating the acute and chronic (nondependent) effects of alcohol on cognition and other behaviors, and their underlying neuroanatomical, neurophysiological, and/or neurochemical substrates. 5. Innate Behavioral Characteristics (disinhibition, challenge) (3 grants) Three grants use selected rat lines (preferring/nonpreferring) to study innate patterns of behavior (disinhibition and electrophysiological parameters) that may predispose to alcoholism and their underlying neurobiological mechanisms. Recommendations Behavioral Paradigms/Phenotypes: More studies are needed in the
areas of tolerance and Neurotransmitter and Brain Regions: More grants are needed to study additional sites in the prefrontal cortex, amygdala, hippocampus, and hypothalamus, and the interactions of the neurotransmitter NMDA, 5HT, and the cholinergic system. Species/Gender: Only four grants are investigating gender differences as part of their specific aims. Since women are more susceptible to the toxic effects of alcohol and the menstrual cycle phase alters sensitivity of the subjective effects of alcohol, more studies are needed on the neural mechanisms of gender differences in the subjective and/or reinforcing effects of alcohol. Neuroadaptive Changes in Neurotransmitters Mediating Ethanol-Induced Behaviors: Sensitization, Relapse, Dependence, Repeated Withdrawals 1. Sensitization (2 grants) Sensitization is the opposite response to tolerance, i.e., the effects of the same dose of a drug become more pronounced with repeated exposure. Two grants are studying neuroadaptive changes underlying sensitization. 2. Dependence, Abstinence/Relapse Models, Neural Mechanisms Dependence Models: Self-Administration, BSR, Incentive Motivation (2 grants) Two grants are examining models of dependence produced by repeated withdrawals from liquid diet or vapor inhalation. Both grants use microdialysis and/or microinjection techniques. Prolonged Abstinence, Relapse, "Deprivation Effect" (3 grants) Three grants are exploring models of relapse in chronically exposed but not dependent animals. It has been shown that when abstinence is imposed after chronic exposure to ethanol, drinking patterns temporarily increase. This has been referred to as the "deprivation effect". 3. Long-term Effects on Brain and Behavior (1 grant) One grant is investigating the neural mechanisms of memory impairments produced by long-term chronic exposure to alcohol. 4. Neurobiological Mechanisms of Protracted Withdrawal (1 grant) One grant is exploring the role of 5HT in mediating the symptoms of ethanol withdrawal. Recommendations Behavioral Paradigms/Phenotypes: More applications are needed to develop models of dependence, craving, relapse, and withdrawal, as well as long- term neurobiological consequences. Neurotransmitter Systems and Brain Areas: Because the cortico-mesolimbic-reward system involves complex interconnections among many structures in addition to the VTA, ACB, and "extended amygdala, more grants are needed to study all the relevant transmitter systems and their interactions in the cortico-mesolimbic reward system, including the prefrontal cortex and hippocampus. Species/Gender: In that females have been shown to be differentially sensitive to alcohol's effects across the menstrual cycle, more studies are needed on gender differences in craving, development of dependence, and relapse. Adolescent Period: Biological Basis for Vulnerability and Underlying Neurobiological Mechanisms 1. Neurobiological and Behavioral Mechanisms and Consequences of Adolescent Drinking Self Administration and Neurotransmitters Systems (2 grants) Two grants are investigating whether characteristics of the dopamine and serotonin systems present in adults are also present in young animals and contribute to excessive drinking in the young. Both grants employ microdialysis, HPLC, and autoradiography procedures to determine if there are differences in regional 5HT and DA content, regional densities of 5HT1 and 5HT2 sites, and binding of 5HT1A and D2 sites in animals 15, 25, and 35 days of age. Brain regions of interest are the cerebral cortex, hippocampus, striatum, hypothalamus, accumbens, and olfactory tubercle. Both grants are using selected lines (P, NP, HAD, LAD) to compare phenotypic differences in these measures. Development of Tolerance/Sensitivity, Low-Dose Stimulatory Effect (3 grants) Three grants are looking at the presence of and/or ontogeny of ethanol responsiveness by measures of low-dose ethanol stimulation, acute and rapid tolerance to ethanol's sedative effects (sleep time), hypothermia, and suppression of startle, as well as differences in emotionality and cognitive functions (Plus Maze and Morris Water Maze learning). Three grants are using rodents and two are using selected lines (P, NP, HAD, LAD). Environmental Factors and Consumption (free choice and operant responding (1 grant) One grant is examining the ontogeny of drinking after weaning (day 22 of age) and the effects of various factors on this development, such as housing conditions, taste aversion conditioning, and pharmacological interventions (fluoxetine, methylphenidate, and buspirone). Selected lines of rats are used (P, NP, HAD, LAD). Long-term Behavioral Consequences of Adolescent Drinking (2 grants) Two grants are studying cognitive and emotional changes in adult animals from selected lines (P, NP, HAD, LAD) that were exposed to ethanol during adolescence, such as orienting to a novel environment, Plus Maze performance, and Morris Water Maze performance. Early Experience and Later Response to Alcohol (3 grants) Three grants are investigating the effects of early exposure to ethanol on later responsiveness to alcohol. All grants use rodents, and one grant employs selected lines. Recommendations Behavioral Paradigms: This is a relatively new initiative in the portfolio. There is now evidencein humans that early alcohol exposure (especially during periods of early late childhood and adolescence) correlates with the development of alcoholism in adulthood. More studies are needed to develop paradigms of alcohol seeking (self-administration and drug discrimination) during the adolescent period to study the underlying mechanisms of ontogeny of alcoholism. Neurotransmitters: Only one study is examining neurochemical markers of alcoholism vulnerability in selected lines of alcohol-preferring and nonpreferring rats. The neurotransmitter systems targeted are DA and 5HT. Clearly, studies of other neurotransmitter systems are needed, particularly their role in the initiation of alcohol-seeking behavior. Species/gender: All four grants are using rats, two are using selected lines. Although two are studying both male and females, gender difference is not a Specific Aim. More studies are needed to examine gender differences. Furthermore, primate models are ideal because of their relatively longer adolescent period. Medications Development The underlying goal of NIAAA's basic neuroscience research grant is to understand the neurobiological mechanisms of alcohol's effect in order to develop treatments for alcoholism, particularly medications. However, for the grants discussed in this section, the focus of at least one specific aim is to test specific compounds, via systemic injection, for their ability to reduce drinking, prevent relapses, or reduce withdrawal symptoms. 1. Operant Responding and Free-Choice Consumption (4 grants) Four studies are using self-administration paradigms (operant reinforcement paradigms and two-bottle consumption) to explore the effectiveness of several receptor antagonists as potential therapeutic agents for reducing alcohol intake. 2. Protracted Withdrawal (1 grant) One grant is studying the effectiveness of various serotonergic compounds (buspirone, 5HT1A partial agonist; mianserin, 5HT2A/2C antagonist, methysergide, a nonselective 5HT antagonist; ICS 205-930, a 5HT3 antagonist) in blocking withdrawal symptoms as measured by drug discrimination and Plus Maze paradigms. Recommendations The most frequently studied compounds for reducing drinking are the opiate antagonists. Clearly, more candidates for potential therapeutic agents are needed drawing from all the relevant neurotransmitter systems. Another recommendation is that more standardized testing procedures for the potential agents be developed. Methodology Development (2 grants) One grant is establishing procedures to measure the effects of ethanol on carbohydrate metabolism and rates and synthesis of amino acid neurotransmitter (glutamate, GABA, and aspartate) in the brain of fully intact, conscious rats using 13C NMR spectroscopy. A second grant is developing an ultrasensitive mass spectrometric procedure for the analysis of neurosteroids in tissue samples and microdialysates of select brain areas of freely moving rats after acute and chronic ethanol administration and during withdrawal. STUDIES OF ACUTE AND CHRONIC EFFECTS OF ALCOHOL IN HUMANS STUDIES OF THE ACUTE EFFECTS OF ALCOHOL ON COGNITION AND IMPULSIVITY: DISINHIBITORY BEHAVIOR Gaps in Knowledge and Research Opportunities (Peter R. Finn, Ph.D.)
CLINICAL NEUROSCIENCE STUDIES OF BEHAVIORS ASSOCIATED WITH ALCOHOL CONSUMPTION IN ALCOHOLISM Gaps in Knowledge and Research Opportunities (John H. Krystal, M.D.)
HPA AXIS: CHANGES AND RISK FOR ALCOHOLISM Gaps in Knowledge and Research Opportunities (Gary Wand, M.D.)
ACUTE AND CHRONIC EFFECTS OF ALCOHOL ON HUMAN SLEEP Gaps in Knowledge and Research Opportunities (Cindy L. Ehlers, Ph.D.)
STUDIES OF ACUTE AND CHRONIC EFFECTS OF ALCOHOL IN HUMANS (Ellen D. Witt, Ph.D.) Human studies, representing about $4.4 million, investigate the consequences of acute and chronic alcohol on cognitive and other behaviors, as well as the underlying structural changes associated with the behavioral deficits using state-of-art imaging technologies. The neural mechanisms of alcohol-motivated behaviors such as craving, have also been studied in humans, but to a lesser extent. Grants for studies of acute and chronic effects of alcohol in humans are detailed below.
Acute Cognitive and Behavioral Studies 1. Acute Effects of Alcohol on Stress Dampening Response/Aggressive Behavior (2 grants) Two grants are studying the acute behavioral effects of alcohol. One grant is examining the effects of alcohol on aggressive responding in women in a laboratory setting. The second grant is examining the ability of alcohol to reduce stress/anxiety using "stress dampening" techniques (i.e., alcohol's effects on the magnitude of physiological responses) and a "cognitive appraisal" model of stress and emotion. 2. Innate Behaviors Antisocial Personality, Behavioral Activation/inhibition/Aggression (2 grants) Two grants are investigating the relationship between innate characteristics, such as antisocial personality and/or temperament (behavioral activation and inhibition), and alcohol-related behaviors (i.e, consumption and/or alcohol-induced aggression). One grant investigates the relationship between antisocial personality, alcohol induced-aggression, and serotonin function. The second grant is investigating the biobehavioral mechanisms (i.e., strength of the behavioral inhibition and activation systems) mediating the relationship between impulsive personality, disinhibited/antisocial personality, and alcohol abuse. Recommendations There is a long history of research on the acute effects of alcohol on cognitive processes, but these studies have largely focussed on memory, divided attention, reaction time, and visuomotor skills. The currently funded research is investigating how alcohol's effects on cognitive processes may have a role in increasing drinking or other alcohol-related behaviors, such as aggression. More research is needed in other areas, such as alcohol's effects on executive functioning, a cognitive construct involving the cognitive regulation of behavior, and how that may increase drinking. More research is also needed on the role of temperament and/or personality characteristics in contributing to excessive drinking and/or other alcohol-related behaviors. Mechanisms of Alcoholic Behaviors 1. Neurotransmitter and Neurohormonal Mechanisms: Behavioral Psychopharmacology (3 grants) Three grants are examining the role of neurotransmitters and neuropeptides in alcohol reinforcement and craving in alcoholics. One grant is studying the interactive contributions of noradrenergic and serotonergic systems to alcohol craving in detoxified alcoholics using cue reactivity paradigms. A second grant is evaluating the role of a glutamate antagonist (ketamine) at the NMDA receptor in producing subjective effects similar to alcohol. The third grant is studying opioidergic mechanisms of reinforcement for coexisting alcohol and nicotine use. 2. Neurotransmitter Mechanisms: Imaging Studies (1 grant) One grant is studying whether the DA system is abnormal in alcoholics, functional consequences of abnormalities, and effects of detoxification. Using PET imaging and multiple tracer methods, this grant is evaluating the DA system in alcoholics in two phases: the DA system at rest and during pharmacological activation. Recommendations While many animal studies are investigating neural circuitry and neurochemical mechanisms of alcohol-motivated behaviors, such as reinforcement, few studies are exploring neurochemical mechanisms in humans. With the advent of new imaging technologies such as PET, and the discovery of ligands/and receptor agonists and antagonists, more studies are needed to investigate neural mechanisms of alcohol-motivated behaviors in humans. Effects of Alcohol on Sleep (1 grant) One grant is investigating whether disruption of sleep continuity and/or loss of slow-wave sleep leads to greater elevations in sympathetic nervous system activity in African American alcoholics, which in turn results in impaired immune function and increased risk for disease. Recommendations Sleep disturbance is a common problem during withdrawal and abstinence which could contribute to relapse to drinking. More research is needed to understand the underlying neural mechanisms of sleep disturbances in abstinent alcoholics, and whether potential medications will ameliorate these sleep disorders. Back to TopCOGNITIVE/BEHAVIORAL/STRUCTURAL DEFICITS NEUROPSYCHOLOGICAL SEQUELAE OF CHRONIC ALCOHOLISM Gaps in Knowledge and Research Opportunities (Marlene Oscar-Berman, Ph.D.) HUMAN BRAIN DYSFUNCTION SECONDARY TO ALCOHOL ABUSE NEUROIMAGING STUDIES OF BRAIN VULNERABILITY TO ALCOHOLISM Gaps in Knowledge and Research Opportunities (Edith V. Sullivan, Ph.D.) COGNITIVE/BEHAVIORAL/STRUCTURAL DEFICITS IN HUMANS Human studies, representing about $4.4 million, investigate the consequences of acute and chronic alcohol on cognition and other behaviors, as well as the underlying structural changes associated with the behavioral deficits using state-of-art imaging technologies. The neural mechanisms of alcohol-motivated behaviors such as craving, have also been studied in humans, but to a lesser extent. Grants for studies of cognitive/behavioral/structural deficits in humans are detailed below. Category No. of Grants FY97
Brain Damage, Cognitive/Motor Dysfunction: Affected Brain Areas, Contributions of Malnutrition, Influences of Polysubstance Abuse, Aging, Gender 1. Neurobehavioral/Cognitive/motor Dysfunction (7 grants) Seven grants are investigating cognitive/motor deficits and their underlying neural substrates in chronic alcoholics and Korsakoff patients using neuropsychological, neurocognitive, neurophysiological, and/or magnetic resonance imaging (MRI) techniques. Motor Functioning (2 grants) Two grants are targeting alcohol's effects on the cerebellum. One grant uses Pavlovian techniques (delayed-classical conditioning tasks involving heart rate, GSR conditioning, eyeblink conditioning, and extinction) to dissociate structures in the medial temporal lobe (amygdala) and cerebellum in mediating associative learning deficits. The other is quantifying regional volumes of the cerebellar hemispheres and vermis with MRI, using a component-process approach to assess motor coordination and motor skill learning, and determining structure-function relationships between specific motor processes and regional cerebellar volumes. Attention, Memory, Executive Processes (4 grants) Two grants study attention and/or memory processes using cognitive tests. One grant is studying deficits in explicit and implicit conceptual memory in chronic alcoholic and Korsakoff patients. The second grant is evaluating cognitive efficiency (principally attention and memory) in subtypes of alcoholics classified on the basis of other substance use/abuse (marijuana, stimulants). Two grants are studying attention, memory, and executive functioning in conjunction with ERP and/or functional MRI (fMRI) to understand the underlying neural mechanisms of these deficits in alcoholics. One of the grants uses fMRI to study localized brain activation during performance of auditory and visual working memory tasks. The fourth grant uses ERP and EEG techniques to study attention and memory processes in abstinent alcoholics classified along several variables including Type I and Type 2 alcoholism, family history of alcoholism, as well as the relationship between antisocial behavior and neurophysiological characteristics. Affective (emotional) and Conative (intentional) Functions (2 grants) Two grants are investigating emotional and intentional abnormalities in chronic alcoholics (with and without Korsakoff's syndrome) and whether these changes are mediated by right frontal or bilateral frontal lobe pathology. 2. Brain Metabolic Changes and Tolerance and Long-Term Abstinence (2 grants) One grant is using magnetic resonance spectroscopy (MRS), which allows noninvasive quantification in vivo of brain metabolites, to investigate the mechanism of alcohol-induced tolerance in humans. A second grant is using MRS to characterize the longitudinal course of metabolic changes (i.e, the ratio of visible choline (Cho) to the neuronal marker n-acetylaspartate (NAA)) in the brains of abstinent alcoholics. 3. Effect of Aging and/or HIV on Cognitive Functioning in Alcoholics (5 grants) Alcohol and Aging (4 grants) One grant is using structural MRI, electrophysiology, and neuropsychological assessments to critically evaluate two opposing models of central nervous system effects of chronic alcohol abuse as they interact with age and gender. Three grants are continuations of ongoing research on the interaction between alcohol and aging. Two of these are investigating emotional, attentional, and intentional processes in alcoholics and age-matched controls to evaluate the ways in which the behavioral consequences of aging and alcoholism are parallel, divergent, and/or interactive. The fourth grant is a continuation of an ongoing longitudinal study of alcoholic and control women using MRI, ERP, and neuropsychological tests to identify cross-sectional patterns of sparing and loss, their interaction with age, and comparability to findings in alcoholic men. Alcohol and HIV (1 grant) One grant is examining the effect of alcohol consumption on neuropsychological function across stages of HIV infection. Recommendations More research is needed in relating cognitive deficits produced by chronic alcoholism to excessive drinking and the inability to benefit from treatment. Methodology Development (1 grant) This grant is developing a method to induce and maintain a steady-state concentration of alcohol in the brain and blood while multiple dependent measures are assessed. Recommendations Technologies which improve our understanding of the neural mechanisms alcoholism and improve treatment are encouraged.
APPENDIX A Subcommittee for Review of Neuroscience and Behavior Portfolio Co-Chairs Henri Begleiter, M.D., Ph.D. Catherine Rivier, Ph.D. Experts in Alcohol-Related Areas Ivan Diamond, M.D., Ph.D. Adron Harris, Ph.D. Harold Kalant, M.D., Ph.D. George Koob, Ph.D. Ting-Kai Li, M.D. Elias Michaelis, M.D., Ph.D. Oscar Parsons, Ph.D. Adolf Pfefferbaum, M.D. Bernice Porjesz, Ph.D. Herman Samson, Ph.D. Boris Tabakoff, Ph.D. Maharaj Ticku, Ph.D. Nora Volkow, M.D. Gary Wand, M.D. Experts in Non-Alcohol-Related Areas Robert Freedman, M.D. ALIGPeter Kalivas, Ph.D. Steven Paul, M.D.
APPENDIX B Experts in Neuroscience and Behavior Marlene Oscar Berman, Ph.D. Fulton Crews, Ph.D. Cindy Ehlers, Ph.D. George Fein, Ph.D. Peter Finn, Ph.D. Kathy Grant, Ph.D. Paula Hoffman, Ph.D. John H. Krystal, M.D. David Lovinger, Ph.D. Leslie Morrow, Ph.D. Catherine Rivier, Ph.D. George Siggins, Ph.D. Linda Spear, Ph.D. Edith Sullivan, Ph.D. Steven Treistman, Ph.D. Gary Wand, M.D. Friedbert Weiss, Ph.D.
APPENDIX C NIAAA Program Staff Walter Hunt, Ph.D. Robert Karp, Ph.D. Yuan Liu, Ph.D. Ellen Witt, Ph.D. Samir Zakhari, Ph.D.
APPENDIX D NIAAA Staff, Representatives from other NIH Institutes, and Guests Megan Adamson, M.D.
Faye Calhoun, D.P.A. Mary Dufour, M.D., M.P.H. Michael J. Eckardt, Ph.D. Joanne Fertig, Ph.D. Richard K. Fuller, M.D. Klaus Gawrisch, Ph.D. Thomas Gentry, Ph.D. Enoch Gordis, M.D. Daniel Hommer, M.D. Nancy Hondros William M. Lands, Ph.D. Ting -Kai, Li, M.D. Burt Litman, Ph.D. Raye Litten, Ph.D. Steve Long Matthew McGue, Ph.D.
Antonio Noronha, Ph.D. Carrie L. Randall, Ph.D. Norman Salem, Jr., Ph.D. Jules Selden, D.V.M., Ph.D. Martin K Trusty Ernestine Vanderveen, Ph.D. Kenneth Warren, Ph.D. Forrest Weight, M.D. Herbert Weingartner, Ph.D. |
Updated: April 1999
National Institute on Alcohol Abuse and Alcoholism (NIAAA)
5635 Fishers Lane, MSC 9304
Bethesda, Maryland 20892-9304
Please send comments or suggestions to the .