DU - Health Concerns
Chemical - The major health concerns about DU relate to its chemical properties as a heavy metal rather than to its radioactivity, which is very low. As with all chemicals, the hazard depends mainly upon the amount taken into the body. Medical science recognizes that uranium at high doses can cause kidney damage. However, those levels are far above levels soldiers would have encountered in the Gulf or the Balkans. For a more in depth discussion of DU's chemical effects, see the section on Health Effects from the Chemical Toxicity of Depleted Uranium in our Environmental Exposure Report, Depleted Uranium in the Gulf (II).
Radiation - Because depleted uranium emits primarily alpha radiation, it is not
considered a serious external radiation hazard. The depleted uranium in armor and rounds
is covered, further reducing the radiation dose. When breathed or eaten, small amounts of
depleted uranium are carried in the blood to body tissues and organs; much the same as the
more radioactive natural uranium. Despite this, no radiological health effects are
expected because the radioactivity of uranium and depleted uranium are so low. For a more
in depth discussion of DU's radiological effects, see the section on Health Effects from the Radiological Toxicity of Depleted Uranium in
our Environmental Exposure Report, Depleted Uranium in the Gulf (II).
What do the experts say on cancer risk?
RAND,
1999. "(N)o evidence is documented in the literature of cancer or any
other negative health effect related to the radiation received from exposure to natural
uranium, whether inhaled or ingested, even at very high doses."
Department of Health and Human Services, Agency for Toxic Substances and Disease
Registry (ATSDR) in 1999 Toxicological Profile for Uranium. "No human cancer of any
type has ever been seen as a result of exposure to natural or depleted uranium."
United Kingdom
Royal Society in May 2001. "Even if the estimates of risk are one hundred
times too low, it is unlikely that any excess of fatal cancer would be detected within a
group of 10,000 soldiers followed over 50 years."
European
Commission March, 2001 report. "Taking into account the pathways and
realistic scenarios of human exposure, radiological exposure to depleted uranium could not
cause a detectable effect on human health (e.g. cancer)."
World Health Organization April, 2001 report. "The
radiological hazard is likely to be very small. No increase of leukemia or other cancers
has been established following exposure to uranium or DU."
European
Parliament April, 2001 report. "The fact that there is
no evidence of an association between exposures – sometimes high
and lasting since the beginning of the uranium industry – and
health damages such as bone cancer, lymphatic or other forms of
leukemia shows that these diseases as a consequence of an uranium
exposure are either not present or very exceptional."
Swedish
Military Headquarters Medical Department Study, January 2003.
"Questionnaires, analysis of uranium in the urine and matching
with the cancer register at the National Board of Health and Welfare
failed to reveal any link between service on the Balkans and cancer
or any other illness." In fact, average urine uranium levels
in two separate groups troops deployed for six months to the Balkans
decreased by 75 percent and 90 percent during their deployment.
The study attributed this decrease to the high natural uranium
levels in Swedish drinking water supplies.
DU Medical
Follow-up Policy. On May 30, 2003, new guidance was issued
by OSD/Health Affairs that clarifies who, why, when, and how the
military should test for possible depleted uranium during and
after deployment and combat operations. The purpose of the testing
is to identify those who may have been exposed to significant
levels of depleted uranium while deployed. After a decade of closely
following many depleted-uranium exposed Gulf War veterans who
were enrolled in the Veterans Affairs depleted uranium medical
follow-up program, the medical community has yet to identify any
untoward health consequences associated with depleted uranium
exposures on the battlefield. Still, it is important to implement
these new guidelines which standardizes the way depleted uranium
tests are performed; directs the compliance with an approved medical
protocol following sound clinical practices; and helps DoD meet
its obligations for ensuring the health of our deployed personnel.
What does medical follow-up tell us?
The voluntary Veterans Affairs DU Medical Follow-up Program began in 1993-1994 with the
medical evaluations of 33 friendly-fire DU-exposed veterans, many with embedded DU
fragments. An additional 29 of the friendly-fire victims were added to the follow-up
program in 1999. In 1998, the scope of the program was expanded to include Gulf War
veterans who may have been exposed to DU through close contact with DU munitions,
inhalation of smoke containing DU particulate during a fire at the Doha depot, or by
entering or salvaging vehicles or bunkers that were hit with DU projectiles. The published
results of these medical evaluations indicate that the presence of retained DU fragments
is the only scenario predictive of a high urine uranium level, and those with embedded DU
fragments continue to have elevated urine uranium levels ten years after the incident. It
is unlikely that an individual without embedded DU fragments would have an elevated urine
uranium level, and consequently any uranium-related health effects. Those individuals with
normal urine uranium levels now are unlikely to develop any uranium-related toxicity in
the future, regardless of what their DU exposure may have been in the Gulf War. Those
individuals with elevated levels of urine uranium ten years after the Gulf War have not
developed kidney abnormalities, leukemia, bone or lung cancer, or any other
uranium-related adverse outcome. The DU Medical Follow-up Program will continue to monitor
those individuals with elevated urine uranium levels to enable early detection of any
adverse health effects due to their continued exposure to embedded DU fragments. |