Winter Wheat Varietal Yield Differences
Related to Canopy Temperature Differences and Soil Water Use
D.C. Nielsen
PROBLEM: Drought stress regularly limits winter wheat yield in the
central Great Plains. I hypothesize that varieties that are better able to
maintain their non-water-stressed canopy temperatures under water stress will
yield higher under water stress than varieties which do not maintain their
non-water-stressed canopy temperature under water stress. Monitoring of stressed
and non-stressed canopy temperatures will therefore be a quick screening tool to
identify varieties adapted to drought stress.
APPROACH: Twelve varieties of winter wheat (TAM107, Jagger, Arlin,
Prowers, Siouxland, Akron, Alliance, Norstar, 2137, Heyne, Halt, Yumar) were
grown in small plots (15' by 40') under two water treatments (rainfed and full
irrigation), replicated three times. Canopy temperatures were monitored daily
with an infrared thermometer between 1300 and 1400 MDT. Cumulative difference
between canopy temperatures of rainfed and fully irrigated plots was compared to
dryland grain yield and biomass for each of the twelve varieties. Soil water was
measured in five varieties on 13 Mar, 20 May, 6 Jun, and 2 Jul 2002 to assess
differences in soil water extraction.
RESULTS: March through June rainfall (2.83 in.) was 36% of average,
fairly evenly distributed (0.96" during vegetative, 1.05" during head extension
to milk, 0.83" during grain-filling). Consequently we were afforded the
opportunity of evaluating differences in yield due to soil water extraction for
the five varieties where soil water was measured.
|
Dryland |
Irrigated |
|
Dryland |
Irrigated |
|
Variety |
------bu/a------ |
Variety |
------bu/a------ |
Akron |
27.9 |
62.9 |
Norstar |
17.0 |
53.9 |
Alliance |
30.9 |
82.8 |
Prowers |
28.5 |
73.6 |
Arlin |
26.1 |
83.1 |
Siouxland |
30.9 |
76.5 |
Halt |
35.8 |
82.0 |
TAM107 |
34.5 |
88.6 |
Heyne |
29.4 |
68.9 |
Yumar |
26.1 |
77.0 |
Jagger |
34.9 |
77.5 |
2137 |
30.7 |
76.9 |
INTERPRETATION: Clearly Norstar is not a variety adapted to the high
temperature, high vapor pressure deficit conditions of the central Great Plains.
For the other four varieties for which soil water was measured, there appears to
be a relationship between yield and soil water extracted during the growing
season. TAM107 was able to extract about 0.6" more soil water during the heading
to milk stage period than the other three varieties (data not shown), and
extracted 1.3" more water than Heyne over the entire spring and summer growth
period. Most of this higher water extraction was noted from the 6th
foot of the soil profile, indicating that part of TAM107's greater drought
tolerance is derived from greater rooting depth/volume.
FUTURE PLANS: The experimental results will be written for publication in
2003. The author may be reached via e-mail at:
D.C. Nielsen
or phone: 970-345-2259. |