ECSTASY: ROLLING ACROSS EUROPE
The Attorney General has determined that publication of this
periodical is necessary in the This report was prepared by the Strategic Europe/Asia/Africa Unit of the Office of International Intelligence. Comments and requests for copies are welcome and may be directed to the Intelligence Production Unit, Intelligence Division, DEA Headquarters, at (202) 307-8726. August 2001
DEA-01008 CONTENTSOver the course of the 1990s, the production, trafficking, and abuse of Ecstasy in Europe and internationally has grown exponentially. Initially, Ecstasy was associated with the rave scene; but since the late 1990s, its abuse has expanded, affecting a broader cross-section of society. The majority of the worlds Ecstasy continues to be produced in clandestine laboratories in the Netherlands and, to a lesser extent, Belgium. Given the increasingly global demand for the drug and the high profit potential derived from its sale, production will likely expand to other areas in the future. Ecstasy trafficking within Europe continues to be dominated principally by European trafficking organizations, moving the drug to consumer markets via overland routes from the production zone. Though many European groups are involved in international Ecstasy trafficking, other groups, including Israeli and Russian drug traffickers, move significant quantities of Ecstasy to international markets, including North America. At the Member State- and the European Union-level, governments are initiating and supporting counter-Ecstasy initiatives, including both law enforcement and public information campaigns. These efforts, coupled with continuing international cooperation, target all aspects of Ecstasy production, trafficking, and abuse. Despite concerted efforts by European legislators and law enforcement officials, as well as their counterparts around the world, Ecstasy will likely remain one of the principal drugs of demand in Europe and internationally. A retrospective evaluation of the drug situation in Europe, over the course of the 1990s, demonstrates an overall increase in the quantity of drugs (all categories) seized. During 1999, the International Criminal Police Organization (INTERPOL) reported increases in the total quantity seized in all major drug categories, including cocaine, heroin, cannabis products, and Ecstasy.1 The most significant increase in Europe, however, came in the seizure of Ecstasy tablets. According to INTERPOL, more than 14.1 million Ecstasy tablets were seized during 1999, nearly triple the 1998 total. The higher seizure totals not only reflect the volume of illegal drugs flowing through the European market, but also more effective reporting of drug seizures in Europe. During the mid-1990s, assessments of the Ecstasy situation in Europe noted the increasing threat posed by Ecstasy as party goers across the European continent were swept into the rave culture. By the late 1990s, the rave phenomenon had gained momentum internationally and the Ecstasy threat was highlighted by unprecedented demand for the drug and an exponential increase in the number of tablets seized. This report focuses on MDMA and other amphetamine analogues collectively known as Ecstasy, addressing the current trends in production, trafficking, and abuse in Europe. PRODUCTION, TRAFFICKING, AND ABUSE The decade of the 1990s witnessed an increase in the production, trafficking, and abuse of synthetic drugs, especially Ecstasy, throughout Europe.2 The rave phenomenon served as the primary vehicle for the perpetuation of MDMA use, as young party goers turned to the drug to maintain the frenetic pace of the popular round-the-clock, high-decibel dance parties. The demand for Ecstasy paralleled the rave scene as it swept across Europe and arrived in the United States. Precursor Chemicals An estimated 80 percent of the worlds Ecstasy is produced in clandestine laboratories in the Netherlands and, to a lesser extent, Belgium using a variety of precursor chemicals, such as safrole/isosafrole, 3,4-MDP2P (3,4-methylenedioxyphenyl-2-propanone), methylamine, etc., in combination with common chemicals. According to Drug Enforcement Administration (DEA) reporting, the chemicals enter the region primarily from Asia, often via Eastern Europe. In addition, clandestine precursor chemical production laboratories have been reported in Eastern Europe. During 1999, according to INTERPOL, several seizures of chemicals used in the production of Ecstasy were effected in Europe. One 5-metric-ton (MT) seizure of piperonal was made in Spain and another of 2.64 MT was effected in the Slovak Republic. The 2.64 MT shipment originated in China and transited Romania and Hungary enroute to the Slovak Republic. Slovak authorities also seized 4.4 MT of 3,4-MDP2P. This 3,4-MDP2P originated in Hong Kong and transited the Czech Republic and Hungary en route to the Slovak Republic. Slovak authorities believe this 3,4-MDP2P was being shipped for the illicit production of Ecstasy in the Slovak Republic or a neighboring country. In addition, during 1999, according to INTERPOL, one laboratory for the production of precursors for the synthesis of synthetic drugs was seized in Poland. In October 2000, Dutch authorities seized 8,250 liters of 3,4-MDP2P in Rotterdam, Netherlands. According to Dutch counterparts, this shipment originated in China and arrived in Lisbon, Portugal, via maritime shipping container from Hong Kong. The 3,4-MDP2P was transported overland to the Netherlands. Based on current conversion rates, a spokesperson for the Dutch forensics laboratory estimated that this amount of 3,4-MDP2P might have produced over 112 million tablets of Ecstasy.
Production Laboratories and Capacity During the 1960s, according to Dutch authorities, the Limburg and Brabant Provinces in the southern Netherlands, along the borders of Germany and Belgium, were known for large-scale amphetamine production. Throughout the 1990s, and today, this region continues to be utilized by producers of synthetic drugs, though the focus has become Ecstasy. Many groups, including Dutch, Belgian, and Russian criminal organizations, are allegedly involved in the production of Ecstasy within the region.
Clandestine laboratories have traditionally been established in the rural areas of these provinces in the southern Netherlands and northeastern Belgium to minimize the likelihood of neighbors or passersby alerting authorities to the presence of the laboratories. The border regions also are attractive to traffickers, who hope to circumvent law enforcement officials by crisscrossing jurisdictions. Additionally, the proximity to Germany, Luxembourg, and France offers easy access to markets and transportation hubs for export throughout Europe and internationally. Laboratory responsibility generally is divided between production sites and tableting sites. These sites range in size from small, free-lance laboratories to large-scale professional-capacity laboratories. The level of technical expertise required for the production of Ecstasy is relatively high. However, there are indications that once a chemist establishes the recipe for the conversion process, individuals lacking formal chemistry training or expertise may assume daily operational responsibilities. This appears to be the case in Belgium, where detailed operating instructions have been found at seized laboratory sites. During 1999, the majority of the Ecstasy production remained concentrated in the southern provinces of the Netherlands. According to the Dutch Annual Synthetic Drug Statistical Report, 23 MDMA-related laboratories were seized during 1999. Laboratory seizures for 2000 will likely exceed 1999 totals, with 23 laboratories seized through October 2000. Among the laboratories seized by Dutch authorities, during 2000, was the largest MDMA production site located in the Netherlands to date. Seizures at this site included 300 kilograms of MDMA powder and approximately 49,000 liters of precursor chemicals.4 In addition, Dutch authorities discovered 44 cylinders of hydrogen gas, several hundred pieces of glassware, and almost 4,000 liters of chemical waste.
Ecstasy production also has been reported in countries neighboring the Netherlands. According to German authorities, one laboratory of multiregional significance, capable of producing approximately 300,000 tablets, was seized during 1999. During the same time period, according to INTERPOL, four Ecstasy laboratories were dismantled in Belgium. Two of these laboratories were seized in the Limburg Province of northern Belgium, near the border with the Netherlands.5 Both laboratories were professionally equipped, and capable of large-scale production.6 During 2000, Belgian authorities dismantled 10 laboratories. Although Western Europe has traditionally been the focal point of Ecstasy production, some minor production has been reported in Eastern Europe. More production is likely to develop in the future given rising demand and the large profit potential of Ecstasy trafficking. The countries of Eastern Europe are perfectly positioned to emerge as producers of Ecstasy, given a combination of factors including the availability of highly skilled and educated chemists, access to chemicals, and established networks for the manufacture and trafficking of synthetic drugsprimarily amphetamine. During 1999, according to INTERPOL, two laboratories for the production of Ecstasy were discovered in the Ukraine. In addition, during 1999, Estonian police found evidence of synthetic drug laboratories believed to be producing Ecstasy. Estonian, Finnish, and Swedish authorities believe that Ecstasy laboratories in Estonia are supplying the Nordic and Baltic markets. This region may also be receiving Ecstasy from Latvia. Authorities in Hungary report that Ecstasy is produced within their country. WHOLESALE AND RETAIL ECSTASY PRICES Estimated Ecstasy Price per Tablet Amounts Shown in US Dollars
Sources: DEA Country Offices: The Hague, Rome, Copenhagen, London, Vienna, Berlin, Madrid, Paris, Bern, 2000.
Production Hazards Ecstasy production is not a risk-free enterprise. Due to the unstable nature of the precursor chemicals, combined with the relative inexperience of the chemists manufacturing the drug, the clandestine laboratories are at risk of explosion. In addition, with the growing number of Ecstasy laboratories in Europe, environmental degradation increasingly is a concern, given the illegal disposal of hazardous waste. According to the Dutch USD, during 1999, more than 100 such dump sites were identified, primarily in the southern Netherlands and near Amsterdam. The disposal of chemical waste is likely to gain attention in the future, as Ecstasy manufacturers, in an effort to avoid detection, transport the chemical waste products across borders and dump them in neighboring countries. According to the DEA Berlin Country Office, the number of burned vehicles found in Germany containing chemical waste from clandestine laboratories is on the rise. Cost/Price Structure Ecstasy is attractive to traffickers due to the significant profits derived from its sale, not only in Europe, but throughout the world. According to DEA reporting, in the Netherlands, the initial investment required to establish a MDMA laboratory is the equivalent of between US$30,000 and US$70,000, depending on the size and production capacity of the laboratory. The average production cost per tablet in the Netherlands is the equivalent of between US$0.25 and US$0.50. Wholesale prices per tablet in the Netherlands range between US$1 and US$2 and street or club prices range between US$7 and US$12. As a result, even close to the production region, Ecstasy traffickers net significant profits at the street level. Trafficking in Europe Europes economic prosperity, sophisticated transportation and communications infrastructures, and reputable financial system have, for years, attracted those engaged in both legitimate and illegitimate commerce. Europes attractiveness to drug traffickers may increase as the European Union (EU) Member States move forward with single-market reforms, continue free movement under the Schengen Agreement, and consider further steps toward broader and deeper integration.7 Attracted by the profits associated with Ecstasy, traffickers smuggle the drug from the Netherlands and Belgium to markets in neighboring countries and internationally. According to DEA reporting, European traffickers, including Dutch, Belgian, and Russian criminal organizations, commonly are involved in Ecstasy smuggling, not only as producers and principal traffickers, but also as logistical support to other smuggling groups. In addition to European trafficking groups, DEA reporting demonstrates the involvement of Israeli criminal organizations in Ecstasy smuggling. There are indications that some of these smuggling groups include individuals of Russian or Georgian descent, who hold Israeli citizenship. The Israeli criminals primarily are involved in the transportation of MDMA to consumer markets outside Europe, relying on producer groups for the supply of Ecstasy.8 The DEAs BCO reports clearly established links to Israeli groups in 12 of the 39 Ecstasy cases initiated by the BCO between 1998 and 2000. Belgiums role as a major center in the international diamond trade often is exploited by the Israeli drug trafficking groups. These traffickers often take advantage of their ethnic connections within the diamond-trading community in an effort to avoid detection by law enforcement officials. The connections to the diamond industry also provide Israeli traffickers with a well-established infrastructure in which to operate. In addition, custom-made luggage designed for transporting diamonds is readily available in Antwerp. This luggage is well-suited for use by drug traffickers smuggling Ecstasy. Israeli traffickers generally are young, well-educated, and multilingual, often with Hebrew/Yiddish, English, and Russian language ability. The groups are highly adaptable and mobile, maintaining contacts throughout Europe and internationally. They use a variety of technologies for communication purposes. Ecstasy trafficking spans the European Continent, with the countries neighboring the source zone not only serving as markets for Ecstasy, but also as transshipment points. Within Europe, local European organizations control Ecstasy trafficking and obtain the drug in the Netherlands and Belgium.
Trafficking organizations utilize a variety of methods to smuggle Ecstasy from the Netherlands and, to a lesser extent, Belgium to various parts of the globe. These countries have long-standing mercantilist traditions and are known for their role as centers for distribution of products throughout Europe and around the world. Their sophisticated intermodal transportation systems include access to local and international airports, world-renowned seaports, extensive railroads, inland waterways, and road transportation companies. These transportation services, coupled with express mail and cargo services, frequently are exploited by traffickers for moving their illegitimate cargo throughout Europe and internationally. Commercial Air Commercial air couriers commonly are used for transporting Ecstasy to international markets. Although these individuals carry relatively small amounts of Ecstasy, travel options are ample and flights frequent from Europes major international airports. Ecstasy frequently is smuggled in carry-on or checked baggage, though external body packages also are used. Couriers often use customized luggage, designed with hidden compartments such as those used for transporting diamonds. To avoid detection by law enforcement officials, trafficking organizations employ a variety of people as couriers, from young American and European women to male Orthodox Jews. The major airports in Europe are the traditional ports of departure for couriers. During 1999, for example, INTERPOL reported that more than 900,000 Ecstasy tablets were seized at, or transited, German airports en route to the United States. Further, more than 1 million tablets destined for the United States were seized, or transited, Amsterdams Schiphol Airport and more than 850,000 tablets were seized at Brussels Zaventem Airport. Similar findings were reported for the airports in Paris and London where approximately 550,000 and 150,000 tablets were seized, respectively. As both trafficking organizations and law enforcement become increasingly sophisticated, routes are likely to diversify. INTERPOL reporting for 1999 noted a movement away from the major European airports by international Ecstasy smugglers. Increasingly, couriers are using secondary, or less heavily traveled, airports (in the region) with flights to the United States, including airports in Switzerland, the Czech Republic, and Iceland. During 2000, several Ecstasy seizures involving couriers arriving at US ports of entry from Iceland were effected. These couriers obtained the Ecstasy and initiated travel in the Netherlands. Rail and Road Within Europe, Ecstasy is smuggled primarily overland in private automobiles or commercial vehicles, with the drugs concealed on a couriers body, in luggage or cargo, or secreted within the chassis of the vehicle. Car ferries frequently are utilized for smuggling Ecstasy into the United Kingdom and Scandinavia. Ecstasy also is smuggled by rail. Traffickers exploit both passenger and commercial rail travel for distribution to southern Europe. Express Mail Express mail parcels have grown in popularity as a means for smuggling Ecstasy and other contraband. A variety of companies offer express delivery service from Europe to locations internationally. Through the use of these express mail service companies, traffickers are able to send packages with virtual anonymity, using false identification as well as false return-address and addressee information. Using these companies also allows traffickers to monitor the progress of shipments on the Internet. Any unusual delays can be identified quickly by the traffickers, alerting them not to pick up or accept packages when they arrive. Although express mail is attractive to traffickers for the reasons stated above, the capacity of express mail packages limits the quantity of Ecstasy sent in each shipment. Express mail parcels are among the most popular methods for moving Ecstasy from Europe to the United States. Throughout the late 1990s, as law enforcement scrutiny of express mail parcels increased in the Netherlands, traffickers moved their transportation operations to Germany, using express mail service centers located along the NetherlandsGermany border. According to the DEA Frankfurt Resident Office, during 1999 and 2000, as German law enforcement officials targeted the use of express mail services for Ecstasy smuggling, traffickers shifted their transportation operations toward France, Spain, Switzerland, and other European countries. This trend is likely to continue, with traffickers shifting their transportation operations further south and east to avoid pressure from law enforcement officials. Air and Sea Cargo As demand for Ecstasy increases around the globe, the volume of Ecstasy smuggled to international markets will increase correspondingly. To transport larger quantities of Ecstasy, traffickers are likely to use air and sea cargo. With Europes sophisticated transportation networks and access to air and maritime commerce through numerous airports and container ports, these methods are likely to become increasingly popular in the future. In July 2000, the USCS and the DEA in Los Angeles, California, seized approximately 2.1 million Ecstasy tablets arriving from France. The tablets were smuggled via airfreight. In August 2000, Canadian authorities seized 84 kilograms of MDMA concealed within a containerized maritime shipment of auto parts. The drugs were concealed in a 20-foot container, which originated in Belgium. The auto parts were destined for Toronto. According to the European Monitoring Center for Drugs and Drug Addiction (EMCDDA) Annual Report on the State of the Drugs Problem in the European Union 2000, Ecstasy and amphetamine are the second most commonly abused drugs in Western Europe, following cannabis products. The EMCDDA estimates that between 1 and 5 percent of individuals, ages 16 to 34, in Europe have taken Ecstasy and/or amphetamine. This may, in part, be a result of the fact that Ecstasy is viewed by many users as a recreational drug, given the method of consumption, tablet form, and the belief that few, if any, harmful side effects result from its use. The Ecstasy-user population is expanding beyond the rave scene, with MDMA reportedly being sold in schools, at sports events, and at other social gatherings in Europe. EMCDDA treatment data indicates that Ecstasy, amphetamine, and hallucinogens were the main drugs in approximately 1- to 2-percent of treatment admissions across Western Europe, while an estimated 65 to 95 percent were for opiate (primarily heroin) use.10 In Central and Eastern Europe, according to the EMCDDA, the popularity of all synthetic drugs has grown over the last 4 years, and has become an important part of the youth dance culture. Law enforcement and treatment officials across the European Continent remain concerned about Ecstasys popularity and use among young people.
According to INTERPOL, Ecstasy seizures in Europe increased dramatically over the past decade. In fact, European Ecstasy seizures during 1999 (14.1 million tablets) nearly tripled the 1998 total (5 million tablets) and the trend continued during the first half of 2000, with more than 8.4 million tablets seized. This trend was mirrored on a global scale with INTERPOL reporting global Ecstasy seizures during 1999 at approximately 22 million tablets, compared to 5.6 million tablets in 1998. INTERPOL reporting indicated that at least 1.6 million of the Ecstasy tablets seized in Europe during 1999 ultimately were destined for the United States. An additional 1 million tablets that were seized in Europe were destined for other consumer markets around the world.
The production, trafficking, and abuse of Ecstasy is a growing problem throughout Europe and internationally. Over the course of the 1990s, government health and law enforcement officials have developed and engaged in public information and enforcement campaigns aimed at countering the Ecstasy threat. Increasingly, governments and law enforcement entities are turning their attention to cooperative efforts to combat Ecstasy. On the European Union-level during 1995, EUROPOL initiated the LOGO PROJECT, a data collection effort aimed at identifying and cataloging various Ecstasy logos and seizure-related information for investigative purposes. More than 500 logos were identified in the 2000 edition of the Synthetic Drugs Catalogue. According to the EMCDDA, as synthetic drug use continues to spread beyond large dance events to geographically diverse clubs, bars, and private parties, public information campaigns will be the most common prevention measure, followed by on-the-spot counseling, outreach work, and crisis intervention. At the European Union Member State-level, both public information antidrug campaigns and law enforcement initiatives have been designed to target the production, trafficking, and abuse of Ecstasy in Europe. The Government of the Netherlands has taken steps to combat Ecstasy through the establishment of national interagency teams of investigators, such as the USD, targeting MDMA production and distribution organizations. In addition, in February 2000, the Dutch Ministry of Health launched a new drug prevention campaign. The program targets high school students, and is designed to combat the increasing use of Ecstasy and amphetamine by young people in discotheques and other clubs. Germany gives high priority to counterdrug law enforcement. German authorities positioned themselves early on to combat Ecstasy smuggling in, and through, Germany, devoting significant resources to the task. German law enforcement agencies remain efficient and effective. Demand reduction programs are active on both the federal and state levels in Germany. Antidrug information campaigns targeting parents have been initiated, as have initiatives for school children. Following an Ecstasy-related death in 1999, the Government of Italy initiated steps toward legislative reform that addressed a variety of amphetamine analogues. Italian authorities also increased enforcement activities at discotheques and clubs. In addition, antidrug public information campaigns targeting all drugs continue to play a central role in the Italian counterdrug strategy.
1The most recent annual statistics available are utilized throughout this report. 2This increase in demand over the course of the 1990s is mirrored in the United States and other countries, paralleling the rave phenomenon, and is likely to continue to expand beyond the rave and nightclub scene as additional producers enter the market, increasing supply and lowering prices. 3For the purposes of this report the terms Ecstasy and MDMA will be used interchangeably. In addition, to remain consistent with INTERPOL reporting, Ecstasy will refer to MDMA and other amphetamine analogues. 4According to the Dutch Unit Synthetic Drugs (USD), 1 kilogram of MDMA powder can be made into approximately 12,500 MDMA tablets. Using this conversion formula, the USD estimates that the 300 kilograms of MDMA powder seized was sufficient to produce approximately 3,750,000 tablets. 5Limburg Provinces exist in the southern Netherlands and northern Belgium. 6According to the DEA Brussels Country Office (BCO), Belgian authorities seized 450,000 Ecstasy tablets at one of the sites. In addition, 19 logo punches and one tableting machine (manufactured in India) were confiscated. As of May 2000, this seizure represented the largest Ecstasy seizure in Belgium. A second site discovered by Belgian authorities resulted in the seizure of 20,000 Ecstasy tablets, a tableting machine, vacuum-sealing equipment, and precursor chemicals. 7Signatories to the Schengen Agreement permit the unfettered movement of goods, services, labor, and capital within the Schengen area which is composed of Austria, Belgium, Denmark, Finland, France, Germany, Greece, Iceland, Italy, Luxembourg, Netherlands, Norway, Portugal, Spain, and Sweden. 8Law enforcement initiatives targeting Israeli Ecstasy trafficking groups will likely be aided in the future by new money laundering legislation passed by the Government of Israel on August 8, 2000. This legislation criminalizes money laundering, creates procedures for criminal and civil forfeiture of the proceeds of money laundering, introduces reporting of the transfers of currency into and out of Israel, and authorizes the issuance of regulations requiring the reporting of irregular transactions by Israeli financial institutions. According to the US Department of State, Israel is in the process of establishing a money laundering authority to coordinate information and activities with Israeli police, customs, banks, and all other relevant entities. 9This calculation was determined using the INTERPOL conversion factor: 1 kilogram of Ecstasy tablets by weight equals 3,000 tablets. 10Information contained in the EMCDDA Annual Report on the State of the Drugs Problem in the European Union 2000. 11This calculation was made using the INTERPOL conversion factor of 1 kilogram of Ecstasy tablets by weight equals 3,000 tablets. Dutch authorities reported the seizure as 170 kilograms of Ecstasy. 12This calculation was made using the INTERPOL conversion factor of 1 kilogram of Ecstasy tablets by weight equals 3,000 tablets. | ||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||