Peer Reviewer’s Confidential Manuscript Assessment for Editors
One or more documents on this Web page is available in
Microsoft Word Format (DOC). You will need Microsoft Word to view and print these documents.
We require peer reviewers to complete an evaluation score sheet on
PCD
Manuscript Central. It is similar to the Reviewer's Confidential Manuscript
Assessment for the Editor, which is available below. The first section
consists of a concise checklist where peer reviewers make their overall
evaluations and recommendations to publish or not. The second section
provides the opportunity for peer reviewers to offer expanded comments to journal
editors; the information in these two sections is viewed by journal editors
only. The third section allows reviewers to make comments directly to
authors.
The Reviewer's Confidential Manuscript Assessment for the Editor is
available on this page as a downloadable Microsoft Word document for
informational purposes only. (Peer reviewers actually evaluate manuscripts
electronically at PCD Manuscript
Central.) Please follow these instructions
to download the form:
- Click the following link to download the form: Manuscript Assessment
(DOC–57K).
- Save the form onto your desktop or hard drive.
- Open the form to view or print.
|
