February 17, 1999
For more information on these science news and feature story tips, please
contact the public information officer at the end of each item at (703)
292-8070.
Editor: Cheryl Dybus
Contents of this News Tip:
As soils develop, rock-derived elements gradually leach out. In the
absence of erosion, ecosystems should reach a state of profound and irreversible
nutrient depletion that would limit rates of plant production, scientists
once believed.
Researcher Oliver Chadwick of the University of California at Santa
Barbara selected sites in Hawaii at which to study the sources and fates
of ecosystem nutrients. Funded by the National Science Foundation (NSF),
he used locations on Hawaii's islands to look at most environmental influences
on ecosystem development, except for the passage of time. Investigations
in ecology, geochemistry and atmospheric chemistry have documented that
drastic nutrient depletion does not occur as predicted.
Says Chadwick, "Ecosystems on highly weathered lava on older Hawaiian islands,
in particular, are sustained at productive levels by nutrients dissolved in rainwater
-and added as phosphorus in atmospheric dust transported from Asia, more than
6,000 kilometers away."
The dependence of biological processes in Hawaii on conditions in,
and transport mechanisms from, central Asia demonstrates that the dynamics
of long-term soil and ecosystem development cannot be evaluated as a local
phenomenon in isolation, Chadwick
believes. "Nowhere on Earth," he says, "is that isolated." [Cheryl Dybas]
Top of Page
Four middle school mathematics textbooks developed with NSF grants were
ranked at the top among 12 textbooks evaluated in a recent independent
study by the American Association for the Advancement of Science (AAAS).
In fact, these top four texts
were the only ones to receive a "high" rating, while the other eight, which are
more wellestablished texts, were rated as "unsatisfactory."
The rankings were based on various rigorous criteria. Content and instructional
analyses were conducted by independent teams of classroom teachers and
college and university faculty. Funding for the evaluative study was provided
by the Carnegie Corporation of New York. Evaluators used a procedure developed
by AAAS' Project 2061 (a research-based K-12 national science and math
education reform effort) to determine how likely the texts are to help
students accomplish six primary learning goals. Established in Project
2061's Benchmarks for Science Literacy, the set of learning indicators
is consistent with the National Council of Teachers of Mathematics (NCTM)
Standards.
The AAAS report indicates that because there has not been an accepted
conceptual basis for evaluating textbooks in the past, such efforts have
largely been unreliable. AAAS reviewed the texts systematically in terms
of what is to be learned by students and emerging content standards and
benchmarks relating to science literacy. Also compared was instructional
effectiveness based on the standards and benchmarks.
According to the study, "there are few excellent middle-grades mathematics
textbook series," and none of the most popular commercially produced textbooks
(i.e., "best-sellers") are among the most highly rated books. [Lee Herring]
Top of Page
Turtles, not birds, have been found to be the closest relatives of crocodiles
and alligators, according to an analysis of the largest available collection
of reptile genes. The study's conclusions contradict decades of research
based on anatomical and fossil studies, which had firmly positioned birds
as the reptile group most closely related to crocs and alligators, a group
known as crocodilians.
Previous studies of gene similarities -- a relatively new tool for
determining relationships between species -- have never agreed with the
more traditional anatomical methods on this
issue, say some scientists. "Turtles turned out to be not where they were supposed
to be on the family tree whenever their genes
were included in a research study," says Blair Hedges, a biologist at Penn State
University who conducted the research
with funding from NSF.
Hedges and graduate student Laura Poling collected new genetic data
and added this new information to all gene-sequence data available for
these species in databases worldwide. The results, says Hedges, provide
stong evidence that the turtle is the crocodile's closest living relative.
With the results of this
study, says Hedges, "I hope paleontologists will take a closer look at reptile
fossils." [Cheryl Dybas] Top of Page
|