skip navigational linksDOL Seal - Link to DOL Home Page
Photos representing the workforce - Digital Imagery© copyright 2001 PhotoDisc, Inc.
www.dol.gov
October 31, 2004    DOL Home > News Release Archives > OSEC/OPA 1999   


Archived News Release--Caution: information may be out of date.

U.S. DEPARTMENT OF LABOR

Office of Public Affairs

OPA Press Release: Conditions in New York City's Garment Industry Unchanged, but Tougher Enforcement Leads to Arrests [10/15/1999]

For more information call: (202) 693-4650

 
	 

The U.S. Labor Department's latest survey of labor standards compliance in garment shops in New York City shows how entrenched labor violations are, but tougher enforcement by the Labor Department led to the arrests yesterday of two garment shop operators, charged with providing false statements to federal investigators.

In its recent compliance survey, the department found that just as many sewing shops violate labor laws by underpaying workers as first found two years ago. But the survey also shows that contractor shops that are monitored by manufacturers or that were investigated previously are more likely to be in full compliance with the minimum wage, overtime and child labor laws. Compliance also was higher in shops that were in business two or more years.

"There is no improvement since the last time we measured," Labor Secretary Alexis M. Herman said. "We found that only 35 percent of the 93 shops we checked followed labor laws. It's disappointing, but the survey also tells us what does work to get better compliance."

Secretary Herman said the arrests, which resulted from investigations by the Wage and Hour Division and the Inspector General of the Labor Department and the U.S. Attorney's Office for the Southern District in New York, "show how serious we are about changing the working conditions for garment workers."

The two arrested were Wei Jan Pan of MYS Fashion, 217 Centre St. and Yoke Lian Ng of Lucky Day Fashion, 91 East Broadway. More arrests will follow. The complaints allege that they lied to investigators about under-payments to employees, cash payments and their records of wages paid and hours worked. The investigation was conducted as part of the Worker Exploitation Task Force, a joint effort of the Labor and Justice Departments to investigate serious instances of worker exploitation and abuse.

The Labor Department has been conducting a multi-pronged "No Sweat" campaign to attack the common practice in the garment industry of underpaying workers, many of whom are immigrants afraid to complain. One part of the strategy has been to encourage manufacturers to monitor labor compliance by the contractors who make clothes for them. The department's surveys in New York and California show that contractors that are monitored are less likely to underpay workers. And the stricter the monitoring, the better the compliance.

In the New York City survey, 48 percent of monitored shops complied with labor laws, compared to 33 percent of those that were not monitored. A 1998 survey in the Los Angeles area found that 56 percent of strictly monitored shops were in compliance.

The department defines monitoring to include reviewing payroll records, reviewing time cards, interviewing employees, providing the contractor with information, advising the contractor about compliance problems, recommending corrective action and making unannounced visits.

"It's clear that we have to do more, but it's also clear what we have to do," Secretary Herman said. "We have to engage retailers in helping to solve the problem, keep the pressure on manufacturers to do stricter monitoring, educate new contractors about the law when they open for business and educate workers about their rights including their right to complain. We will continue to concentrate investigations in the garment industry to the full extent that our resources allow. And we will continue to make criminal referrals when we find conditions that warrant it."

The Labor Department found nearly $815,065 in back wages due 1,621 workers in the shops surveyed. There were no child labor violations. This is the first New York City garment survey that obtained information about the effects of monitoring by manufacturers.


Archived News Release--Caution: information may be out of date.




Phone Numbers