Issue # 27 - June 2002
Welcome to the Contaminated
Sediments News, a monthly review of recent journal articles,
issues in the press, upcoming conferences, and other news. This
website will replace the Contaminated Sediments Newsletter, which
was published quarterly through the summer of 2000. Items for the
CS News are chosen from the results of a detailed search of a number
of scientific and technical publication databases, as well as from
searches of media publication databases (including newspapers and
magazines).
Check back to this site frequently to see each new issue of the
Contaminated Sediments News, and visit the CS
News Archive to find past issues.
Note: The summaries found on this website are based
on articles from the press and from peer-reviewed publications,
and they represent the opinions of the original authors. The views
of authors expressed herein do not necessarily state or reflect
those of the United States Government, and shall not be used for
advertising or product endorsement purposes. Reference herein to
any specific commercial products, process, or service by trade name,
trademark, manufacturer, or otherwise, does not necessarily constitute
or imply its endorsement, recommendation, or favoring by the United
States Government.
Recent News
- Modeling Contaminated Sediments
in New York Harbor - Over the next 10 years, millions
of tons of New York Harbor's chemically contaminated silt, sand,
and sediment must be dredged. Experts say that knowing what
chemicals are in the mud, how the harbor sediments move, and
where the pollutants originate could save hundreds of millions
of dollars by reducing disposal costs. Dr. Rankin, an assistant
professor at the Stevens Institute of Technology in Hoboken,
is studying the New York Harbor Estuary to create a computer
model that will provide the most sophisticated analysis ever
of how a harbor system actually works. The pressure to complete
this model is great because the Army Corps of Engineers will
dredge more than 65 million cubic yards of silt and sand from
the estuary over the next decade in order to make room for new
supercargo tankers with deeper drafts. If the harbor is not
dredged, the big tankers will go elsewhere, ultimately costing
the region hundreds of millions of dollars in lost revenue and
thousands of jobs. However, because of the contamination, sediment
disposal will be expensive - it is expected to cost up to $50
per cubic yard.
The estuary research and modeling effort, known as CARP (Contaminant
Assessment and Reduction Project), will evaluate both environmental
impacts to living resources and economic impacts to the port
of New York. The project has already provided new information
about the effects of wind on currents in various bays which
suggests that pollutants found in some areas originate miles
away from where they are ultimately deposited. For instance,
part of the contamination in the Kill van Kull might originate
from factories or sewage plants miles away, drawn by the flushing
action. Research also revealed that in some water samples
near Staten Island, traces of DDT were found that did not
show any evidence of weathering in the environment. This suggests
a leak, perhaps from a land-based source that has not been
identified.
Source: Johnson, Kirk. The Problem Is Deep, and Its Name
Is Mud; Before New York Harbor Is Dredged, Toxic Sediments
Must Be Mapped. The New York Times, June 3, 2002 pB1(L)
col 01 (35 col in).
Recent Journal Articles of Interest
- Influence of Sediment and
Feeding on Elimination of PAHs in Amphipods - The
authors studied the elimination of selected PAH congeners
by Diporeia spp., a sediment-dwelling amphipod. Elimination
of non-polar organic contaminants (such as PAHs) was thought
to be dominated by fecal elimination in this amphipod, which
encapsulates the fecal material in a peritrophic membrane.
This study tested elimination of PAHs in the presence of three
solid substrates, and also under water-only conditions. The
results showed in general that substrates with a higher sorptive
capacity had a greater influence on the elimination process.
The presence of a solid substrate enhanced elimination. The
study found that elimination via the fecal route was generally
insignificant, except for the elimination of BaP in the presence
of sediment. The authors conclude that these results refute
the earlier hypothesis that fecal elimination is the dominant
route of elimination for Diporeia spp. Rather, the
main mechanism for elimination of contaminants is primarily
via passive diffusion from the organism with subsequent sorption
to the solid substrate.
Source: Lotufo, GR., Landrum, PF. 2002. The influence
of sediment and feeding on the elimination of polycyclic
aromatic hydrocarbons in the freshwater amphipod, Diporeia
spp. Aquat Toxicol; 58(3-4):137-49.
- NOAA Sediment Quality Guidelines
Applied to Australian Harbor - Sediment quality
guidelines (SQGs) developed by NOAA were applied to the highly
contaminated sediments of Port Jackson (Australia) to estimate
possible adverse biological effects of contaminants to benthic
animals. Sediments in the Port Jackson estuary are polluted
by a wide range of contaminants. The NOAA guidelines indicated
that lead, zinc, DDD, and DDE are the most likely contaminants
to cause adverse biological effects in Port Jackson. The NOAA
SQGs were also used to estimate the probability of sediment
toxicity for contaminant mixtures. This was done by determining
the number of contaminants exceeding an upper guideline value
(effects range medium, or ERM) to predict probable adverse
biological effects. Based on the results of this analysis,
about 1% of the harbor has sediment containing more than ten
contaminants exceeding their respective ERM concentrations.
Based on NOAA data, these sediments have an 80% probability
of being toxic. Sediment with six to ten contaminants exceeding
their respective ERM guidelines extend over approximately
4% of the harbor and have a 57% probability of toxicity. These
areas are located in the landward reaches and in proximity
to the most industrialised part of the bay. The validity of
using the NOAA SQGs outside North America has not yet been
demonstrated, but the screening approach used here was to
identify contaminants of concern and to determine areas of
environmental risk.
Source: Birch, GF, Taylor, SE. 2002. Application of
sediment quality guidelines in the assessment and management
of contaminated surficial sediments in Port Jackson (Sydney
Harbour), Australia. Environ Manage; 29(6):860-70.
- Assessment of Dioxins and
Furans in Sediment and Crabs Near Pulp Mills -
This study was undertaken to find out whether coastal sediment
contamination conditions had changed as a result of the reduction
in output of dioxins and furans by pulp and paper mills in
British Columbia. In the late 1980s, mill process changes
and source controls at mills along the British Columbia coast
resulted in dramatic reductions in both the concentrations
of polychlorinated dibenzo-p-dioxins and dibenzofurans (PCDD/Fs)
and the TEQ (2,3,7,8-TCDD toxic equivalents). But questions
lingered regarding whether the sediments were acting as contaminant
sources or sinks, whether crab uptake pathways had stayed
the same, and whether improvement was faster at some sites
than others. This study interpreted PCDD/F sources and composition
trends at different sites using sediment and crab principal
components analysis (PCA) models. The authors also used two
indices, one that measured the relative inputs of chlorine
bleaching PCDFs and PCP-related PCDDs, and one index that
measured the relative inputs of PCP wood preservatives and
pulp mill effluents. The study found that proportions chlorine
bleaching TCDFs have generally decreased in importance from
all sites. However, the results also showed that PCDFs produced
during chlorine bleaching accumulate in crabs more readily
than the PCDDs. The authors state that because the PCA composition
for the harbor sites has not changed much since the mid-1990s,
this is an indication that the ecosystem may not be actively
recovering.
Source: Yunker MB, Cretney WJ, Ikonomou MG. 2002. Assessment
of chlorinated dibenzo-p-dioxin and dibenzofuran trends
in sediment and crab hepatopancreas from pulp mill and harbor
sites using multivariate- and index-based approaches.
Environ Sci Technol; 36 (9):1869-78.
- Predicting the Fate of
Sediment and Pollutants in River Floodplains -
The authors present a model of the future redistribution and
radioactive decay of cesium from sediment in floodplains at
the Los Alamos National Laboratory, New Mexico. The model
was constructed using a theory of sediment redistribution
in alluvial valley floors that tracks particle-bound pollutants,
and in addition considers sediment storage within floodplains.
The model was designed to specifically include particle exchange
with the floodplain, which the authors feel is a factor too
often ignored by the use of hydrodynamic models of in-channel
processes. Results of the model show that floodplain storage
significantly reduces the rate of sediment delivery, allowing
50% of the cesium currently residing in the valley floor to
decay radioactively before leaving National Lab site. The
rate of sediment overturn in the valley was found to be significantly
controlled by the sediment exchange rate with the floodplain
(as determined by sensitivity analysis). This outcome underscores
the fact that flood plain sedimentation and erosion can have
a strong influence on the redistribution of contaminants in
floodplain environments. The authors also discuss the implications
of these results on different river basin management scenarios.
Source: Malmon DV, Dunne T, Reneau SL. 2002. Predicting
the fate of sediment and pollutants in river floodplains
. Environ Sci Technol; 36(9):2026-32.
- Hormone Variation in Alligators
Exposed to Contaminated Sediments - The researchers
studied variation in levels of plasma thyroxine (T4) in juvenile
alligators (Alligator mississippiensis) from 3 different
sites of varying contamination (T4 is a hormone known to be
affected by organochlorine contaminants). Based on historical
sediment data, high, low, and intermediate contaminant exposure
sites were chosen for sampling. In 1999, alligators from the
intermediate contamination site had the highest T4 concentrations.
In 2000, alligators from the low contamination site had the
highest T4 concentrations. Alligators from all sites had higher
T4 concentrations in May 2000 compared to May 1999. The results
did not show any sexual dimorphism among mean T4 concentrations
within any of the sites. The authors conclude that mean plasma
T4 concentrations did not match the available data regarding
sediment contaminant levels.
Source: Gunderson MP, Bermudez DS, Bryan TA, Crain DA,
Degala S, Edwards TM, Kools SA, Milnes R, Guillette LJ Jr.
2002. Temporal and spatial variation in plasma thyroxine
(T4) concentrations in juvenile alligators collected from
Lake Okeechobee and the northern Everglades, Florida, USA.
Environ Toxicol Chem; 21(5):914-21.
- Landscape Metrics and Estuarine
Sediment Contamination - This paper reports on
the use of a quantitative relationship between landscape metrics
and sediment contamination to analyze 75 small estuarine systems
across the mid-Atlantic and southern New England regions of
the USA. The method was originally developed for small systems
in the Chesapeake, so adjustment for differing hydrology,
sediment characteristics, and sediment origins was included
in the analysis. Statistical models were created for sediment
metals, organics, and total PAHs. The variation in sediment
metals levels was explained with landscape metrics including
the percent of nonforested wetlands, percent of urban area,
and point source effluent volume and metals input. The first
two metrics were also important for sediment organics and
total PAH levels. Sediment characteristics and hydrology were
found to be important in mitigating the influence of these
landscape metrics on contamination levels.
Source: Paul JF, Comeleo RL, Copeland J. 2002. Landscape
metrics and estuarine sediment contamination in the mid-Atlantic
and southern New England regions. J Environ Qual; 31(3):836-45.
- Biological Responses of
Worms Exposed to PAHs - The impact of the sediment-associated
PAH fluoranthene on the behavior, reproduction, and toxicokinetics
of the worm Lumbriculus variegates was examined. At
the lowest test concentration, the number of worms increased,
but at the intermediate level the number of worms was lower
and similar to the control after exposure. Worms exposed to
the intermediate level of PAH also exhibited increased reproduction
when fed a trout chow mixture. Based on total biomass, the
intermediate exposure level with food was the only treatment
higher than the nonfed control. The behavioral responses of
the worms were measured as changes in biological burial rate,
which increased toward a plateau as the concentration increased
from the control to the highest level of PAH in sediment.
Uptake and elimination rates of the contaminant declined with
increasing treatment concentration. The authors explained
this disconnect between increasing burial rates and decreasing
toxicokinetics rates demonstrates that the toxicokinetic processes
are dominated by uptake and elimination to interstitial water.
Source: Landrum PF, Gedeon ML, Burton GA, Greenberg MS,
Rowland CD. 2002. Biological responses of Lumbriculus
variegatus exposed to fluoranthene-spiked sediment.
Arch Environ Contam Toxicol;42(3):292-302.
- Multiple Stressor Effects
on Benthic Biodiversity - The authors report on
the use of historical environmental monitoring data (1984-1999)
and GIS technology to identify the combinations of natural
and anthropogenic stressors that best accounted for observed
patterns of benthic biodiversity in Chesapeake Bay. GIS was
used to link spatial databases for benthic biodiversity, water
quality, and sediment contaminant concentrations. A statistical
model was used to explain observed patterns of benthic biodiversity.
The results showed that natural stressors alone accounted
for as much as 34% of the variation in benthic biodiversity,
and combinations of anthropogenic contaminants accounted for
as much as 48% of the variation. The consideration of both
types of stressors accounted for approximately 73% of the
observed variation in benthic biodiversity of Chesapeake Bay.
The authors conclude that these results suggest that benthic
biodiversity is a function of complex interactions among natural
and anthropogenic stressors, and that new risk assessment
methodologies must be developed to assess the risk of multiple
stressors at a regional scale.
Source: Preston BL, Shackelford J. 2002. Multiple stressor
effects on benthic biodiversity of Chesapeake Bay: implications
for ecological risk assessment. Ecotoxicology;11(2):85-99.
- Accelerated Fractionation
of Heavy Metals in Contaminated Sediments - This
paper discusses a new method for conducting an accelerated
sequential extraction of trace elements from solid samples.
It had previously been shown that rotating coiled columns
(RCCs) used in counter-current chromatography could be applied
to the dynamic leaching of heavy metals from sediments. The
authors tested this and obtained a solid sample as the stationary
phase under the action of centrifugal forces, while different
aqueous solutions were continuously pumped through. This procedure
only required 4 to 5 hours, whereas traditional sequential
extraction requires several days. In addition, the new method
results in minimal loss of the solid sample. In the scenarios
tested, the recoveries of readily leachable forms of lead,
zinc, and cadmium were higher using the dynamic extraction
in RCC method. Continuous extraction in RCC may help to estimate
the contents of leachable forms and their potential risk for
the environment better than traditional sequential extraction.
Source: Fedotov, P S, Zavarzina, A G, Spivakov, B Ya, Wennrich,
R, Mattusch, J, Titze, K de P C, Demin, V V. 2002. Accelerated
fractionation of heavy metals in contaminated soils and
sediments using rotating coiled columns. J Environ Monit;
4(2):318-24.
- Multielement Sequential
Extraction Method for Metal Partitioning in Sediments
- This paper describes the use of an experimental design approach
for the optimisation of a multielement extraction method.
The method passes one extractant solution at varying pH through
a contaminated soil sample using centrifugation. Factors such
as the nature and concentration of the acid and the rate of
centrifugation were studied in order to obtain the optimum
conditions. Once optimum conditions had been obtained, sequential
leaches were analyzed and chemometrics were used to identify
the composition of each component.
Source: Santamaria-Fernandez R, Moreda-Pineiro A, Hill
SJ. 2002. Optimization of a multielement sequential
extraction method employing an experimental design approach
for metal partitioning in soils and sediments. J Environ
Monitr; 4(2):330-6.
- Biomagnification of Dioxins
and Furans in Ducks and Their Prey - This study
measured concentrations of polychlorinated dibenzo-p-dioxins
and dibenzofurans (PCDDs/DFs) in common cormorants, tufted
ducks, and their prey (fish and bivalves). The muscle tissues
of cormorants had higher total PCDDs/DFs-TEQ than those of
tufted ducks, and results of cluster analysis indicated that
the residue distribution pattern of PCDD/DF homologues was
different between the two species. Biomagnification factors
(BMFs) were estimated from bivalves as prey to ducks, and
the biota-sediment accumulation factors (BSAFs) of PCDDs/DFs
were estimated using shijimi clam and fish samples against
sediment from the lake. Results of these analyses are further
discussed by the authors.
Source: Kang YS, Yamamuro M, Masunaga S, Nakanishi J. 2002.
Specific biomagnification of polychlorinated dibenzo-p-dioxins
and dibenzofurans in tufted ducks (Aythya fuligula), common
cormorants (Phalacrocorax carbo) and their prey from Lake
Shinji, Japan. Chemosphere; 46(9-10):1373-82.
- Recent Sedimentary History
of Anthropogenic Impacts on a Mexican Estuary -
Changes in nutrient fluxes to the Culiacan Estuary in Mexico
were studied with the use of 210Pb geochronology and sediment
profiles of nutrients (carbon, phosphorus and nitrogen). C:N:P
elemental ratios showed that excess nutrient input began in
1948 when the area was cleared for agricultural use. Nutrient
input increased around the 1970s, along with population growth
in Culiacan City. Other ratio measurements made during the
study indicate that nutrient enrichment in this area is mostly
influenced by sewage that comes down the Culiacan River.
Source: Ruiz-Fernandez AC, Hillaire-Marcel C, Ghaleb B,
Soto-Jimenez M, Paez-Osuna F. 2002. Recent sedimentary
history of anthropogenic impacts on the Culiacan River Estuary,
northwestern Mexico: geochemical evidence from organic matter
and nutrients. Environ Pollut 2002; 118(3):365-77.
- Effects of Oil and Grease
on the Vaporization of Organic Compounds from Contaminated
Sediments - Often sediments contaminated with hazardous
compounds such as polynuclear aromatic hydrocarbons (PAHs)
are dredged and stored in confined disposal facilities, and
many of theses sediments also contain substantial amounts
of oil and grease. This study was conducted to determine variations
in the volatilization of sediment contaminants under the presence
of oil and gas. An uncontaminated sediment sample was spiked
with motor oil and PAHs. The air emission flux of three compounds
(dibenzofuran, phenanthrene, and pyrene) from the oily sediment
was compared to that from the same sediment without oil. The
flux measurements for all three compounds were significantly
lower in the presence of oil. In addition to the experiment,
a model was built to test whether the oil served as an additional
compartment for the partitioning of the chemicals. The comparison
of experimental data and the model results showed that this
was in fact the case.
Source: Ravikrishna, R., Valsaraj, K. T., Thibodeaux, L.
J., Reible, D. D. 2002. Effects of oil and grease on
the vaporization of organic compounds from contaminated
sediments. Environmental Engineering Science; 19(2):101-113
- Emission to Air of Volatile
Organotins from Contaminated Sediments - Dredged
harbor sediments contaminated with tributyltin (TBT) were
tested to determine their contribution to air pollution with
respect to organotin compounds. Methylbutyltins that sorbed
to the analytical substrate were analysed by gas chromatography,
while other butyltins were converted into butyltin hydrides
prior to analysis by gas chromatography. Results showed that
TBT-contaminated sediments released mainly methylbutyltins,
but seawater did not significantly release this contaminant,
even on prolonged evaporation using mechanical agitation and
active ventilation. The authors suggest that emission of methylbutyltins
from contaminated sediments probably occurs only from the
surface of the sediment, and they also discuss the environmental
and management implications of these results.
Source: Vella, Alfred J., Vassallo, Roderick. 2002. Emission
to air of volatile organotins from tributyltin contaminated
harbour sediments. Applied Organometallic Chemistry;
16(5):239-244
- What Controls the Mixed-Layer
Depth in Deep-Sea Sediments? - This study was undertaken
to investigate the dependence of the mixed-layer depth (also
called the depth of biogenic particle mixing) on different
biogeochemical characteristics. To do this, the authors compiled
a set of deep-sea estimated measures of mixed-layer depth,
particulate organic carbon (POC) flux, biogenic mixing intensity
(Db), and POC reactivity from 36 sites in three oceans. Results
of this compilation showed that mixed-layer depth varies systematically
with POC flux. Further analysis suggested that the mixed-layer
depth is much more likely to be controlled by POC flux than
biogenic mixing intensity, and that the mixed-layer depth
is negatively related to oxygen penetration into the sediment.
The authors conclude that because there is not much food available
to benthos in the deep sea, POC flux controls the size and
activities of the sediment-mixing benthos, which, in turn,
control the thickness of the mixed-layer depth.
Source: Smith, C. R., Rabouille, C. 2002. What controls
the mixed-layer depth in deep-sea sediments? The importance
of POC flux. Limnology and Oceanography; 47(2): 418-426
- Trace Metal Ingestion and
Assimilation by the Green Mussel - The authors
investigated trace metal ingestion and assimilation by the
green mussel Perna viridis. Uptake of the metals (cadmium,
selenium, and zinc) was through a mixture of diatoms and sediment
at concentrations both above and below the pseudofeces production
levels. Diatoms and sediment were labeled with different radio
labels, and through comparison of the ratios of these labels
in the particle mixture, mussel tissues and pseudofeces, the
authors demonstrated that the mussels were able to selectively
ingest the diatom particles at a high particle load. Efficiency
of selection for diatoms increased with increasing amount
of sediments in the particle mixture. The assimilation of
selenium and zinc by the mussels was reduced with the presence
of sediment within the mussel gut, which the authors suggest
was due to the resorption of metals onto the sediment, leading
to a quicker passage of metals through the digestive tract
and a lower proportion of metals subjected to digestion. However,
the presence of diatoms did not significantly affect metal
assimilation from ingested sediment. The authors conclude
that particle selection may potentially alter metal influx
from ingested food sources, particularly at high particle
concentrations. Selective feeding of nutritious particles,
in addition to high assimilation efficiency, may increase
metal influx into mussels via their diet.
Source: Ke, C., Wang, W. 2002. Trace metal ingestion
and assimilation by the green mussel Perna viridis in a
phytoplankton and sediment mixture. Marine Biology.
140(2):327-335
Upcoming Conferences and Events
- International Symposium on
Sediment Quality Assessments - The Fifth International
Symposium on Sediment Quality Assessments will be held October
16-18, 2002 in Chicago, Illinois. This symposium is the fifth
in a series being organized by the Aquatic Ecosystem Health
& Management Society (AEHMS).
The five principal areas for the 2002 conference are:
- Sediment Transport and Contaminant Flux
- Sediments and Watershed Management
- Microbial Pathogens: Are Sediments A Risk?
- Weight of Evidence and Risk-Based Decision Making
- Emerging Technologies for Assessment and Remediation of
Sediments
For further information, see the symposuim website at:
http://www.aehms.org/SQA5_event.html
-
Conference on Contaminated
Soils, Sediments & Water - The 18th Annual International
Conference on Contaminated Soils, Sediments & Water will
be held October 21-24, 2002 in Amherst, Massachusetts. The
theme of this year's conference is "Expediting and Economizing
Cleanups," and live equipment demonstrations will augment
the exhibition section. Visit the conference website www.umasssoils.com
for more information.
- Second International
Conference on the Remediation of Contaminated Sediments
- The Second International Sediment Remediation
Conference will be held in the autumn of 2003 in Venice,
Italy. Organizers say the city is an ideal setting for a
conference on this topic because of the sediments remediation
efforts being exerted there by the local, regional, and
national governments. The Call for Abstracts brochure is
expected to be available in July 2002, and abstracts to
be considered for the program will be due in December 2002.
To request a copy of the Call for Abstracts, visit the Sediment
Remediation Conference website.
email
the newsletter
|