DOEGenomes.org
Human Genome Project Information  Genomics:GTL  Microbial Genome Program  home
-
skip navigation
Home Site Index Home
What's New
About the HGP Home Ethical, Legal, and Social Issues Home
Research Education Medicine Media
Gene Therapy Gene Therapy Privacy Issues and Other Legislation
Gene Testing Gene Therapy Patenting Issues in Genetics Other Ethical, Legal, and Social Issues
Gene Therapy DNA Forensics Courts and the New Genetics
Gene Therapy

Minorities, Race, and Genomics


 Subject Index

 Send the url of this page to a friend

News
 What's New
 Meetings Calendar
 Media Guide

Basic Information
 FAQs
 Glossary
 Acronyms
 Links
 Genetics 101
 Publications

About the Project
 What is it?
 Goals
 Progress
 History
 Ethical Issues
 Benefits
 Genetics 101

Medicine &
the New Genetics

 Home
 Gene Testing
 Gene Therapy
 Pharmacogenomics

 Disease Information
 Genetic Counseling

Ethical, Legal,
Social Issues

 Home
 Privacy Legislation

 Gene Testing
 Patenting
 Forensics
 Genetically Modified Food
 Behavioral Genetics
 Minorities, Race, Genetics
 Genetics in Courtroom

Education
 Teachers
 Careers
 Students
 Webcasts Audio/Video
 Images
 Videos
 Chromosome Poster
 Presentations
 Genetics 101
 
Genética Websites en Español

Research
 Home
 Sequencing
 Instrumentation
 Mapping
 Bioinformatics
 Functional Genomics
 ELSI Research
 Recent Abstracts
 US,Intl. Research Sites
 Funding

Publications
 Human Genome News
 Chromosome Poster
 Primer Molecular Genetics
 To Know Ourselves
 Your Genes, Your Choices
 List of All Publications

  ???Search This Site


 Contact Us
 Privacy Statement

 Site Stats and Credits

DOWNLOAD:
PDF Handout

The U.S. Department of Energy's (DOE) Human Genome Program devoted 3% of its annual Human Genome Project (HGP) budget toward studying the ethical, legal, and social issues (ELSI) surrounding the availability of genetic information. Some of these projects studied potential effects of ELSI, and others sought to educate professionals through literature, conferences, workshops, and multimedia. Among the programs funded by DOE ELSI were educational materials for physicians, educators, students, clergy, and judges and other legal professionals.

In 2004, DOE sponsored a Nature Genetics supplement called, Genetics for the Human Race. This supplement originated from a May 2003 workshkop held by the National Human Genome Center at Howard University in Washington DC. The workshop, Human Genome Variation and 'Race', and this special issue of Nature Genetics were proposed by scientists at Howard University and financially supported by the Genome Programs of the US Department of Energy, through its Office of Science; the Irving Harris Foundation; the National Institutes of Health, through the National Human Genome Research Institute; and Howard University. The supplement contains articles based on the presentations at this workshop.

In 2002, DOE sponsored the production of a 24-page genomics insert in the Journal for Minority Medical Students. Distributed in all issues of its spring issue, the supplement covers basic genetics, Zeta Phi Beta's genetics education program, the genetics of sickle cell anemia, medical genetics, and ELSI issues.

Another ELSI project was with the National Educational Foundation of Zeta Phi Beta Sorority, Inc. The sorority planned and conducted major informational conferences on the Human Genome Project and its impact on minority communities. The conferences covered a variety of topics--from basic genetics and HGP history to gene testing and careers in genetics. Held in Chicago in 2003, Atlanta and Washington, D.C. in 2001, Pennsylvania Legislative Black Caucus in 2001, Philadelphia in 2000, and New Orleans in 1999, the conferences have sparked numerous follow-up meetings and training sessions led by members of the educational foundation. [Proceedings from the 2000 conference are available online.]

In 1996, DOE HGP partnered with Tuskegee University to present the 3-day conference, “Plain Talk About the Human Genome Project.” The conference brought together internationally recognized scientists, bioethicists, and legal scholars from government, industry, and academia to discuss the ELSI of the use and misuse of genetic information. In rare "both-sides-of-the-argument" discussions, speakers expressed apprehension about the project and the use of its resulting genetic information. Concerns ranged from the fear of actuarial classifications of "genetic exceptionalism" to the burden African Americans would face if they were among those labeled by some as a biological underclass. Focused particularly on how the data might affect African Americans, the meeting also was a vehicle for students from Tuskegee and other historically black institutions to meet with genome scientists, hear the issues, and explore career possibilities in genomics. Proceedings from this conference are available as a book, Plain Talk About the Human Genome Project, 292 pp., 1997. [Contact for book: Tuskegee University, 800/848-9322 (press 4) or 334/727-8525.]

About 150 leaders of minority communities came together in June 1997 at the University of Maryland, Baltimore (UMB) to learn about the Human Genome Project. The DOE HGP-sponsored meeting's goals were to (1) inform minority communities about the Human Genome Project by explaining its potential benefits and clarifying its possible ELSI implications; and (2) make the aspirations and interests of these communities known to genome project scientists and policymakers. This program grew from organizers' concerns about an information vacuum among minorities regarding the genome project and the possibility that suspicions would arise about the project's intent. Proceedings from this conference were combined with an additional essay to form the book, The Human Genome Project and Minority Communities: Ethical, Social, and Political Dilemmas, edited by Raymond Zilinskas (Monterey Institute of International Studies) and Peter Balint (University of Maryland). It addresses the divisions between minority groups and the scientific community, particularly in the area of medical and genetic research. 144 pp., 2000. [Available through bookstores, including online suppliers.]


Resources for More Information

Organizations

DOE-Sponsored Journal Supplements
  • Genetics for the Human Race, Nature Genetics supplement, September 2004, Vol 36, Issue 11s.
    • Race and the human genome, by Ari Patrinos, [Full text or PDF (103K)]
    • Changing the paradigm from race to human genome variation, by Charmaine DM Royal & Georgia M Dunston [Full text or PDF (95K)]
    • Forensic genetics and ethical, legal and social implications beyond the clinic, by Mildred K Cho & Pamela Sankar [Full text or PDF (104K)]
    • What we do and don't know about race, ethnicity, genetics and health at the dawn of the genome era, by Francis S Collins [Full text or PDF (330K)]
    • Conceptualizing human variation, by SOY Keita, RA Kittles, CDM Royal, GE Bonney, P Furbert-Harris, GM Dunston & CN Rotimi [Full text or PDF (102K)]
    • Implications of biogeography of human populations for race and medicine, by Sarah A Tishkoff & Kenneth K Kidd [Full text or PDF (270K)]
    • Genetic variation, classification and race, by Lynn B Jorde & Stephen P Wooding [Full text or PDF (850K)]
    • Will tomorrow's medicines work for everyone? by Sarah K Tate & David B Goldstein [Full text or PDF (161K)]
    • Are medical and nonmedical uses of large-scale genomic markers conflating genetics and race? by Charles N Rotimi [Full text or PDF (118K)]
    • Assessing genetic contributions to phenotypic differences among racial and ethnic groups, by Joanna L Mountain & Neil Risch [Full text or PDF (226K)]
    • Implications of correlations between skin color and genetic ancestry for biomedical research, by EJ Parra, RA Kittles & MD Shriver [Full text or PDF (1,666K)]

  • Human Genome Project Black Bag, Journal for Minority Medical Students supplement, Spring 2002.
    Special 32-page insert covers basic genetics, Zeta Phi Beta's genetics education program, the genetics of sickle cell anemia, medical genetics, and ELSI issues.
Articles

Meeting Proceedings

Real Audio Files

Send the url of this page to a friend


To read pdf files, download the free Acrobat Reader software.

Last modified: Thursday, October 28, 2004

Home * Contacts * Disclaimer

Base URL: www.ornl.gov/hgmis

Office of Science Site sponsored by the U.S. Department of Energy Office of Science, Office of Biological and Environmental Research, Human Genome Program