|
|
Appendix 4-B
Violence in the Media and Its Effect on Youth Violence
Americans have been concerned about the prevalence of violence in the media and its
potential harm to children and adolescents for at least 40 years. The body of research on
television violence has grown tremendously since the first major Federal reports on the
subject in 1972 and 1982 (National Institute of Mental Health, 1982; U.S. Surgeon
Generals Scientific Advisory Committee on Television and Social Behavior, 1972).
During this period, new media emergedvideo games, cable television, music videos,
and the Internet. As they gained popularity, these media, along with television, prompted
public concern and research attention.
Recent surveys depict the abundance of (primarily electronic) media in U.S. homes
(Roberts et al., 1999; Woodard, 1998) and the extensive presence of violence within the
media landscape (Wilson et al., 1997, 1998). They also show that the proliferation of new
media has expanded the opportunities for children to be exposed to media violence at home.
Current psychological theory suggests that the interactive nature of many of these new
media may affect childrens behavior more powerfully than passive media such as
television. Research to test this assumption is not yet well developed, and accurate
measurement is needed to determine how much violence children are actually exposed to
through various mediaand how patterns of exposure vary among American youths.
In reading this discussion of research on the impact of media violence on
Americas youth, a few major points should be kept in mind:
- First, research on the effects of media violence examines many kinds of outcomes in
young people. Researchers have focused primarily on aggression, an outcome that
psychologists define as any behavior, physical or verbal, that is intended to harm another
person. Physical aggression may range from less serious acts, such as pushing or shoving,
to more serious physical contact and fighting, to very serious violent acts that carry a
significant risk of injury or death, such as assault, robbery, rape, and homicide. Some
studies have focused on how media violence affects aggressive thinking, including beliefs
and attitudes. Other studies have focused on the effects of media violence on aggressive
emotionsthat is, on emotional reactions, such as anger, that are related to
aggressive behavior. In this discussion, the label "violence" is reserved for
the most extreme end of the physical aggression spectrum.
- Second, as noted in Chapter 4, the preponderance of evidence indicates that violent
behavior seldom results from a single cause; rather, multiple factors converging over time
contribute to such behavior. Accordingly, the influence of the mass media, however strong
or weak, is best viewed as one of the many potential factors that help to shape behavior,
including violent behavior.
- Third, a developmental perspective is essential for understanding how media violence
affects youth behavior and for framing any coherent public health response to it. Although
this report focuses generally on the violent behavior of adolescents, it is critical to
understand how children are influenced by and respond to media violence, especially in
order to recognize and help those who are particularly susceptible to adverse effects.
Most youths who are aggressive and engage in some forms of antisocial behavior do not
become violent teens and adults. However, it is well established that many violent
adolescents and adults were highly aggressive and even violent at younger ages, and the
highly aggressive child is at increased risk of growing up to be a more aggressive young
adult (Nagin & Tremblay, 1999). Because influences that promote aggressive behavior in
some young children can contribute to increasingly aggressive and even violent behavior
many years later, it is important to understand the early factors that may play a role in
later outcomes.
- Fourth, a growing body of research supports theories that explain how exposure to media
violence would activate aggressive behaviors or attitudes in some children. Humans begin
imitating other individuals at a very early age, and young children learn many motor and
social skills by observing the behavior of others (Bandura, 1977). Social interactions
shape the scripts for behavior that children acquire, but observational learning is a
powerful mechanism for acquiring social scripts throughout childhood (Huesmann, 1998).
Most researchers agree that such observational learning is probably the major
psychological process underlying the effects of media violence on aggressive behavior.
This same process could explain how prosocial behavior depicted in the media might
encourage positive behavior in children (Friedlander, 1993; Harold, 1986; Mares, 1996).
Home | Contents | Previous | Next
|