Gasoline Prices
The high cost of gas and fuel in Northern Michigan
is an issue I have long been concerned with. All Americans have been
hit hard by the high price of gasoline, but nowhere is the impact more
evident than in rural areas such as northern Michigan, with its long
driving distances.
As of March 25, 2002, nationwide prices for
gasoline surged a record 14 cents over the prior two weeks, in the
largest two‑week jump in 50 years. This is on top of a nearly
9‑cent‑a‑gallon increase in the two previous weeks. These numbers are
from a Lundberg Survey of 8,000 stations nationwide. The national
average for regular at self‑serve pumps as of Friday, March 25, was
$1.35 for regular, $1.44 for mid‑grade and $1.53 for premium, according
to Lundberg. Already, prices have climbed again.
Part of the price increase is likely because of
OPEC agreed‑on production cuts that will last through June, the seasonal
change to different gas formulations with a related draw‑down of
inventory before the change, the beginnings of an economic recovery, and
perhaps, increased motor vehicle traffic because of reduced air travel.
Even industry analysts acknowledge that the potential for continued
volatile prices, as in the past two years, is still there.
I was very active in 2000 and 2001 in encouraging
the Federal Trade Commission (FTC) to investigate price spikes for gas
and oil in the Midwest that occurred in the summer of 2000. The FTC
report, issued on March 30, 2001, found no illegal price
fixing among manufacturers, but it described action by individual
refiners and oil companies to
Agame the system@
and maximize profit.
I believe that the FTC report doesn=t
deal with the real issue ‑ exorbitant oil company profits arising from
higher gasoline and oil prices. I co‑sponsored the Gasoline Price Spike
Act of 2001, to tax the oil industry on these windfall prices when they
are above a reasonable rate of return. This bill would also make
reformulated gasoline more widely available and less expensive, and
would provide a $6,000 tax credit to buyers of American‑made ultra
efficient vehicles.
Senator Carl Levin recently completed Senate
subcommittee hearings into the same 2001 summer price spikes and into
market conditions which have boosted the average gallon price since
early January of this year. The subcommittee's investigation suggested
that mergers and consolidations in the industry, as well as industry
practices such as zone pricing, manipulation of the gasoline supply to
maximize profit, and price setting in response to competitors rather
than costs of production have contributed to high prices. Senator Levin
suggested that these practices, while not presently illegal, ought to be
considered an "anti-competitive act".
One of the reasons that I voted against H.R. 4, the
energy bill adopted by the House of Representatives in 2001, was its
lopsided favoring of big oil companies with huge tax breaks. The
compromise bill that may be finalized in conference between the House and
the Senate this year may be somewhat more balanced.
I certainly understand your strong feelings on this
issue, and your frustration at having to deal with companies at the retail
level which seem to raise their prices simultaneously, literally
overnight, without much in the way of explanation or apparent real cause.
As last year=s FTC
investigation shows, the federal laws against illegal price fixing are not
always effective in dealing with big oil companies working to increase
profit as much as possible, while staying within the literal limits of the
law.
You can be sure that I will keep your concerns in
mind if this matter is discussed further in the House. I will also pay
close attention to provisions in any finally enacted energy bill that may
result from a compromise between the House and Senate versions, with an
eye toward removing tax breaks and unfair advantage for big oil.